Constitutional Court: Voluntary Pension Funds Can Be Withdrawn as Lump Sum or in Instalments
The Constitutional Court (MK) has decided that pension fund benefits from voluntary membership can be paid out as a lump sum or periodically, according to the choice of the participant, widow/widower, or child. The ruling was read out during the pronouncement of Decision Number 139/PUU-XXIII/2025, which partially granted the petition for judicial review of Article 161 paragraph (2) and Article 164 paragraph (2) of Law Number 4 of 2023 concerning the Development and Strengthening of the Financial Sector (P2SK).
“Adjudicating, partially granting the petitioners’ request,” said Chief Justice Suhartoyo while reading the verdict at the MK Building, Jakarta, on Monday. Through this decision, the MK declared that the provision requiring pension benefits to be paid periodically contradicts the 1945 Constitution and has no conditionally binding legal force as long as it is not interpreted that the payment of pension benefits for voluntary pension fund participants can be made as a lump sum or periodically according to the participant’s wishes.
The court also altered the interpretation of Article 164 paragraph (2) of the P2SK Law, which previously limited the first payment of pension benefits as a lump sum to a maximum of 20 percent of the total benefits. According to the court, membership in both Employer Pension Funds (DPPK) and Financial Institution Pension Funds (DPLK) is not mandatory, so participants must be given the freedom to determine how their pension benefits are disbursed.
Nevertheless, the court reaffirmed that the main purpose of a pension fund is to maintain income continuity during retirement. “If this provision is ignored and pension benefits can be taken as a lump sum, then the main purpose of having a pension fund cannot be achieved,” said Justice Enny, quoting the court’s legal considerations. Therefore, the MK assessed that the choice of lump sum or periodic disbursement must still consider the provisions of laws and regulations governing pension funds.
The petitioners argued that pension fund benefits derived from voluntary membership should be able to be disbursed as a lump sum if the participant needs them, for example, to start a business or for other economic needs. They considered that the provisions in the P2SK Law requiring periodic payments could potentially harm the constitutional rights of pension fund participants. Through this ruling, the MK provides room for voluntary pension fund participants to determine their own mechanism for disbursing pension benefits, either as a lump sum or in stages.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-voluntary-pension-funds-can-be-withdrawn-as-lump-sum-or-in-instalments-1782751901)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5627952/mk-dana-pensiun-sukarela-bisa-dicairkan-sekaligus-atau-bertahap), translated from Indonesian