Constitutional Court Urged to Limit Local-Wisdom Exemption for Land Burning
Jakarta (ANTARA) — Two Indigenous community members, Putes Lekas and Era Purnama Dewi, have asked the Constitutional Court (MK) to limit the exemption from the prohibition on land burning when it is justified in the name of local wisdom.
“The term ‘community’ in the provision is considered too broad, creating the potential for parties outside customary-law communities to exploit it to justify land burning practices under the pretext of local wisdom,” said the applicants’ lawyer, Fahrur Rozi, in a statement in Jakarta on Wednesday, referring to Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management (PPLH).
Fahrur said the exemption from the ban on clearing land by burning, as set out in the law, still raised questions about legal certainty.
In response, Putes, chair of the North Barito Regional Council of the Indigenous Peoples Alliance of the Archipelago and a member of the Dayak Taboyan Indigenous community, and Era Purnama, a resident of Kampar Regency, Riau, filed a petition for a judicial review at the Constitutional Court on Wednesday. They are challenging Article 22 point 24 of the Appendix to Law No. 6 of 2023 on Job Creation, which amended Article 69(2) of the PPLH Law.
He said the applicants had asked the Court to interpret the provision constitutionally so that the exemption from the ban on clearing land by burning would apply only to members of customary-law communities who had practised it across generations in accordance with local wisdom.
“There is no clear limitation on who is meant by ‘community’ and therefore entitled to the exemption,” he said.
Fahrur said both Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities had practised land clearing by burning.
As a result, he continued, traditional farming by customary-law communities risked being treated in the same way as land burning by other parties, including for commercial purposes.
He also explained that the Dayak Taboyan community continued to practise rotational farming using slash-and-burn methods as part of a traditional agricultural system passed down through generations.
Burning, he added, was also part of a land-management system linked to soil fertility, the cultivation of local rice varieties, and a sequence of rituals and customary knowledge.
Fahrur said the Indigenous community’s practices were subject to control mechanisms and collective responsibility that differed from land burning for plantations or other large-scale commercial activities.
The consequences of treating the practices alike had been directly felt by both applicants. Putes, a traditional leader of the Dayak Taboyan in Central Kalimantan, said his community’s long-standing rotational slash-and-burn farming had never caused forest and land fires because it was governed by strict customary rules and local rituals.
“Moreover, the issuance of Presidential Instruction No. 11 of 2026 on Strengthening Enforcement of the Ban on Land Clearing by Burning has further marginalised Indigenous farmers, because it instructs that the prohibition be applied indiscriminately,” Putes said.
Meanwhile, Era Purnama, a resident of Kampar, Riau, suffered respiratory problems after being exposed to haze from forest and land fires from September to October 2026.
Era said the harm to people’s right to a good and healthy environment occurred because the state had no clear normative criteria for distinguishing burning for customary farming from commercial burning.
In their petition, the applicants asked the Court to rule that Article 22 point 24 of the Appendix to Law No. 6/2023, which amends Article 69(2) of Law No. 32/2009, is contrary to the 1945 Constitution and conditionally unconstitutional, meaning it has no binding legal force unless interpreted in a specified way.
They also proposed that subsistence land clearing be subject to conditions: no more than two hectares per household, cultivation of local varieties, firebreaks around the land, and no commercial purpose or involvement by holders of business permits.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-urged-to-limit-local-wisdom-exemption-for-land-burning-1794405314)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5847423/mk-diminta-batasi-pengecualian-bakar-lahan-atas-nama-kearifan-lokal), translated from Indonesian