Constitutional Court: TNI Personnel Who Commit Ordinary Crimes Should Be Tried in General Courts
The Constitutional Court (MK) has granted a judicial review challenge to the Military Courts Law. In its reasoning, the court said that Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI) personnel who commit ordinary crimes as set out in the Criminal Code should be tried in general courts.
“Grants the petitioners’ application in its entirety,” Chief Justice Suhartoyo said as he read out the ruling at the Constitutional Court building in Central Jakarta on Thursday (15 October 2026).
The petition was filed by Lenny Damanik and Eva Meliani Br Pasaribu under case number 260/PUU-XXIII/2025. Lenny Damanik is the mother of a 15-year-old junior high school student, identified by the initials MHS, who died after being assaulted by First Sergeant Riza Pahlivi.
Eva Meliani is the daughter of journalist Rico Sempurna Pasaribu, who died after being set alight in Karo. The petitioners challenged Article 9(1), Article 43(3) and Article 127 of Law No. 31/1997 on Military Courts against Article 1(3), Article 24(1), Article 27(1) and Article 28D(1) of the 1945 Constitution.
The court ruled that Law No. 31/1997 on Military Courts is contrary to the 1945 Constitution. It also ruled that the law would have no binding legal force on a conditional basis unless amended within no more than two years of the ruling being delivered.
The court said military-court jurisdiction over military offences is justified by the particular nature of the cases, not by the offender’s status as a TNI member. It said ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel should be tried in general courts.
“Thus, the justification for military-court jurisdiction over military offences lies in the particular nature of the cases, not merely in the offender’s status as a soldier. In this context, the jurisdiction of general courts concerns ordinary crimes under the Criminal Code committed by TNI personnel, which should fall within the jurisdiction of general courts,” Associate Justice Arsul Sani said.
Constitutional Court Justice Enny Nurbaningsih said Article 9(1) of Law No. 31/1997 does not specify that TNI personnel should be tried in general courts when they commit ordinary crimes. She said there was no legal basis for retaining military-court proceedings for ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel in peacetime, or when the general courts are functioning normally.
Enny said, however, that the court allowed for ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel during wartime in combat zones to be tried in military courts. She said any such limitation must be clearly regulated.
“If it is considered necessary to extend military-court jurisdiction to handle ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel during wartime in combat zones, the relevant provisions must be formulated specifically and narrowly, and may be provided as an exception,” Enny said.
The court also referred to the principle of impunity, which describes a situation in which perpetrators of violations cannot, or cannot effectively, be held accountable. It said that the further an offence is from having a distinctively military character, the weaker the case for keeping it within military-court jurisdiction.
“Limiting military-court jurisdiction is not intended to diminish the standing of military courts as part of the judicial power, but to ensure that their special jurisdiction is used only for cases that genuinely have a military character. By contrast, trying ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel in general courts is consistent with the need to ensure accountability and independence, and to prevent the risk of impunity,” Enny said.
The court said lawmakers must promptly draft a new Military Courts Law. The full ruling is as follows:
Grants the petitioners’ application in its entirety;
Declares Law No. 31/1997 on Military Courts contrary to the 1945 Constitution and conditionally without binding legal force unless amended within no more than two years of this ruling being delivered;
Declares that if lawmakers do not amend the law within no more than two years of this ruling being delivered, Law No. 31/1997 on Military Courts will be contrary to the 1945 Constitution and will have no binding legal force;
Orders that this ruling be published in the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia as required.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-tni-personnel-who-commit-ordinary-crimes-should-be-tried-in-general-courts-1792057948)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8708609/mk-prajurit-tni-lakukan-tindak-pidana-umum-harusnya-diadili-di-peradilan-umum), translated from Indonesian