Constitutional Court Ruling Should Spur Comprehensive Audit of Internet Quota Governance, Says IAW
The question is no longer whether expiring internet quota is permitted, but how much economic value belonging to the public has been lost for years without any choice, without compensation, and without ever being audited openly.
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Indonesian Audit Watch (IAW) considers Constitutional Court Decision Number 273/PUU-XXIII/2025 to be a momentum for the government to audit the governance of internet quota and prepare a restitution mechanism for consumers.
IAW Founding Secretary Iskandar Sitorus said in Jakarta on Saturday that the Court has affirmed that remaining internet quota carries economic value and must therefore be protected.
“The question now is no longer whether expiring quota is allowed, but how much economic value belonging to the public has been lost for years without any choice, without compensation, and without ever being audited openly,” Iskandar said.
According to him, the Constitutional Court ruling requiring telecommunications operators to provide options so that remaining internet quota can still be used does not fully resolve the issue.
Iskandar assessed that the ruling read out by the Court on Thursday (23 July) does not abolish the validity period provisions of internet packages. Operators may still offer various types of packages, both with and without rollover facilities.
However, he said, operators are no longer permitted to erase all remaining benefits purchased by customers simply because the package’s validity period has expired.
“What the Court corrected is not the existence of validity periods, but a system that allows consumers’ economic rights to vanish just like that without a fair protection option,” he said.
In its considerations, the Constitutional Court stated that remaining quota is an economic benefit that has been paid for by consumers, and is therefore related to the protection of property rights and fair legal certainty as guaranteed by the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
IAW considers the ruling to have changed the way internet quota is viewed. Until now, the relationship between operators and customers was considered finished once a package’s validity period ended, even if unused quota remained.
According to Iskandar, commercial interests can no longer be the sole basis for erasing economic benefits that the public has already paid for.
In its advocacy, IAW estimates the value of unused internet quota at around Rp63 trillion per year, with an accumulation of around Rp613 trillion over the long term. However, he stressed that this figure remains an estimate that must be tested through an official government audit.
“IAW’s calculation is not a court verdict nor the result of a final audit. Precisely for that reason, the state must test it using primary data held by operators, from the number of packages sold, the volume of quota used, quota that expired, to its accounting treatment,” Iskandar said.
He stressed that historical restitution must be based on verifiable data. The government needs to know the number of affected customers, the amount of quota lost, the method of calculating transaction value, and the most appropriate form of compensation.
In addition, IAW considers that an audit is not sufficient merely to examine operators’ financial statements. The examination also needs to cover the digital systems that record package purchases, data usage, remaining quota, rollover mechanisms, and the automatic deletion process when validity periods end.
According to Iskandar, the examination should ideally be conducted in five layers: a regulatory audit, an information systems audit, an accounting audit, a fiscal audit, and an audit of consumer losses.
IAW also urged the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) to examine state financial management related to PT Telkom Indonesia as a state-owned enterprise (BUMN) and its subsidiaries.
As for private operators, Iskandar said oversight could be carried out through examinations of tax management, non-tax state revenue (PNBP), the use of frequency spectrum, and the effectiveness of supervision by the relevant ministries.
Nevertheless, he reminded that the Constitutional Court ruling cannot be directly interpreted as evidence that all operators have committed criminal acts.
“The Constitutional Court ruling is a correction to the consumer protection system, not a criminal verdict. If allegations of fraud, collusion, or abuse of authority are later found, everything must still be proven through audits and applicable legal processes,” Iskandar said.
He added that the Constitutional Court ruling is not the end of the expiring internet quota controversy, but the beginning of a process to open historical data, calculate the value of consumers’ lost rights, and determine whether collective restitution to the public is necessary.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-ruling-should-spur-comprehensive-audit-of-internet-quota-governance-says-iaw-1784980487)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5665849/iaw-putusan-mk-momentum-audit-menyeluruh-tata-kelola-kuota-internet), translated from Indonesian