Constitutional Court Ruling Deemed Only a First Step, IAW Pushes for Historic Restitution of Expired Internet Quota
Jakarta – A Constitutional Court ruling requiring telecommunication operators to provide options so that remaining internet quota can still be used is considered not to have fully resolved the issue. Secretary of the Indonesian Audit Watch (IAW) founders, Iskandar Sitorus, is urging the government not only to apply the ruling to future services but also to open up data on internet quota that has been forfeited over the years in order to calculate the rights consumers have lost. According to him, Constitutional Court Decision Number 273/PUU-XXIII/2025 should serve as a momentum to conduct a comprehensive audit of internet quota governance while preparing a historic restitution mechanism for the public who have lost benefits from data packages they had already paid for.
“The Court has affirmed that remaining quota holds economic value and must receive protection. The question now is no longer whether forfeited quota is permissible, but how much economic value belonging to the public has been lost over the years without choice, without compensation, and without ever being openly audited,” Iskandar told reporters on Saturday, 25 July 2026. He stated that the ruling read out on 23 July 2026 does not eliminate the existence of package validity periods. Operators may still offer various packages, whether with rollover facilities or not. However, operators are no longer justified in wiping out all remaining benefits a customer has paid for simply because the validity period has ended.
“What the Court corrected is not the existence of a validity period, but a system that allows consumers’ economic rights to disappear without a fair protection option,” he said. In its considerations, the Court emphasised that remaining quota constitutes an economic benefit already paid for by the consumer, thus relating to the protection of property rights and fair legal certainty as guaranteed by the 1945 Constitution. The Court also requested operators to provide service options such as quota accumulation, validity period extension, benefit transfer, compensation, refunds, or other protection schemes without imposing additional costs on customers. IAW assesses that the ruling simultaneously changes the way the issue of internet quota is viewed. Previously, operators considered the relationship with the customer concluded once the package validity period ended, even if some quota remained unused. Now, according to Iskandar, the commercial interests of companies can no longer be the sole basis for eliminating economic benefits that have been paid for by the public.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-ruling-deemed-only-a-first-step-iaw-pushes-for-historic-restitution-of-expired-internet-1784955057)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1916278-putusan-mk-dinilai-baru-langkah-awal-iaw-dorong-restitusi-historis-kuota-internet-hangus), translated from Indonesian