Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Constitutional Court Ruling and Expert Calculators of State Financial Losses

| | Source: Kompas Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Constitutional Court Ruling and Expert Calculators of State Financial Losses
Image: Kompas

Our legal system has just been jolted by a pendulum swinging with force. The Constitutional Court (MK), through Decision Number 28/PUU-XXIV/2026 read out on 9 February 2026, has issued an absolute directive: only the BPK, armed with the mandate of Article 23E of the 1945 Constitution, possesses the constitutional authority to assess, declare, and determine the amount of state financial losses. Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., poet and Associate Justice of the US Supreme Court from 1902 to 1932, once reminded us, “The life of the law has not been logic: it has been experience.” In the courtroom, truth is often no longer a verse of poetry about justice, but a series of frozen numbers that determine human fates. There, in corruption cases, the law demands mathematical precision to answer one crucial question: how much state money has been plundered. On the judicial bench, these loss figures become a kind of “holy grail”. Without them, the case structure collapses because they are an absolute prerequisite to fulfilling the three elements of the criminal corruption offence under Law No. 31 of 1999 as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001. Those three elements require: first, the element of unlawful acts; second, the element of enriching oneself or another party or corporation; and third, the element of state financial losses. If even one of these three elements, including the state financial losses element, is not met, the criminal criteria automatically fail, and the corruptor can walk free. Therefore, to determine whether state financial losses exist and how much they actually amount to, the court calls upon an “expert”. Here, we must draw a clear demarcation so that the public and law enforcers no longer stumble over the confusion in the term “expert witness”. In criminal law terminology (Article 1 numbers 26 and 27 of the Criminal Procedure Code), a witness is an entity who sweats at the scene of the event; they must see, hear, and experience the incident themselves, not from rumours or based solely on what they heard from others without experiencing it firsthand. In contrast, the expert provider comes from a vacuum. They were never there when the state coffers were breached. They appear solely bringing the scalpel of “special competence” in the field of state finances to illuminate the darkness of the case. The question is, from which institution’s womb must this loss-calculating expert be born? In reality on the ground, so far, Law Enforcement Agencies (APH) have pragmatically preferred to knock on the door of the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP) to bring in the expert. The reason is very human and urgent: time effectiveness and geographical scope.

More from 6 April 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-ruling-and-expert-calculators-of-state-financial-losses-1775645616)
Originally published by Kompas (https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2026/04/06/09110081/putusan-mk-dan-ahli-penghitung-kerugian-keuangan-negara?utm_source=ABC&utm_medium=rss), translated from Indonesian
Print