Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Constitutional Court Rules Voluntary Pension Funds Can Be Disbursed as Lump Sum

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Constitutional Court Rules Voluntary Pension Funds Can Be Disbursed as Lump Sum
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia - The Constitutional Court (MK) has partially granted a judicial review petition regarding Law Number 4 of 2023 on the Development and Strengthening of the Financial Sector (UU P2SK), which previously required the disbursement of voluntary pension fund benefits to be carried out in stages.

In the reading of Decision Number 164/PUU-XXIII/2025 on Friday (29/06/2026), MK Chief Suhartoyo stated that the norm in Article 164, paragraph (1), point d of the UU P2SK, which regulates the phased disbursement of pension funds, contradicts the 194/1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.

The article in the UU P2SK is also deemed to have no binding legal force unless interpreted as follows: “except for the payment of pension benefits where participation is voluntary, formed from severance pay and/or service period appreciation pay and rights compensation pay, which are paid either as a lump sum or periodically.”

The Court noted that the petitioners, consisting of eight workers and retirees including Lukas Saleo, Warjito, and Haeruddin Fallah, primarily challenged the lack of choice regarding whether voluntary or supplementary pension programs are paid periodically or as a lump sum.

In relation to this, the Court has issued a ruling in Constitutional Court Decision Number 139/PUU-XXIII/2025. Based on the ruling’s operative part, the norms of Article 161, paragraph (2) and Article 164, paragraph (2) of Law 4/2023 have been declared contrary to the 1945 Constitution and lack binding legal force.

Consequently, the Court opined that the petitioners’ application has lost its object. As a legal consequence regarding the norm of Article 164, paragraph (1), point d of Law 4/2023, Suhartoyo stated, it must be declared affected by the aforementioned Court decision.

Constitutional Judge Enny Nurbaningsih added that with the exception provided in the ruling, the validity of the norm in Article 164, paragraph (1) is automatically adjusted so that pension benefit payments for voluntary participants—including spouses and children, formed from severance pay, service appreciation pay, and rights compensation—can be paid as a lump sum or periodically according to the wishes of the participant, subject to prevailing laws and regulations, particularly those governing pension funds.

Therefore, regarding the norm of Article 164, paragraph (1), point d of Law 4/2023, the Court considers it to be contrary to the 1945 Constitution and without binding legal force unless interpreted to exclude the payment of pension benefits for voluntary participation, formed from severance pay and/or service period appreciation pay and rights compensation pay, which can be paid as a lump sum or periodically.

This interpretation was made by the Court to maintain consistency and synchronisation with Constitutional Court Decision Number 193/PUU-XXIII/2025.

“Thus, the petitioners’ arguments regarding the norm of Article 164, paragraph (1), point d of Law 4/2023 being contrary to the 1945 Constitution are well-founded. However, because the Court’s interpretation does not exactly match what the petitioners requested, the argument a quo is legally justified in part,” said Constitutional Judge Enny Nurbaningsih.

As is known, the judicial review application registered under Number 164/PUU-XXIII/2025 was filed by eight workers/retirees, namely Lukas Saleo, Warjito, Haeruddin Fallah, Achmad Yani, Nikolas Pamula Lambe, Ismet Akuba, Arfan Rasyid, and Imam Budiyono.

They are employees of PT Freeport Indonesia, employees and former employees of PT Kuala Pelabuhan Indonesia, and employees of PT Unilever Indonesia. The petitioners challenged the provisions for pension benefit payments in Article 161, paragraph (2) regarding periodic payments, as well as Article 164, paragraph (1), point d, and Article 164, paragraph (2) of the UU P2SK.

The loss experienced by the petitioners is real, specific, and potential. Petitioners I-VI and VIII, who are still working, face the potential loss of being unable to take pension benefits as a lump sum upon retirement. Meanwhile, Petitioner VII, who has been retired since 1 December 2024, has already been directly disadvantaged as they have not received their lump sum pension rights to date.

In the initial hearing held at the MK on Wednesday (24/09/2025), the legal counsel for the petitioners, Zen Mutowali, emphasised the fundamental difference between mandatory public pension programs and supplementary private pension funds.

According to him, the current regulations cause loss to workers by restricting the rights of private pension fund participants to receive pension benefits as a lump sum.

“The applicability of the object of this petition is a rule that shares the same substance and causes loss or potential loss of the petitioners’ constitutional rights because we are not receiving pension benefits as a lump sum,” said the counsel.

“Furthermore, these pension benefits are supplementary in nature, and the participation was a voluntary choice by the petitioners as workers from the beginning, and constitutes the property of the petitioners as individual citizens, which should not be reduced by the state,” the counsel added during the hearing.

Additionally, the petitioners argued that the provisions of Article 164, paragraph (1), point d and Article 164, paragraph (2) of the UU P2SK, which limit the disbursement of pension benefits to a maximum of 20 per cent as a lump sum, contradict the principle of protecting citizens’ rights as guaranteed by the 1945 Constitution.

More from 30 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-rules-voluntary-pension-funds-can-be-disbursed-as-lump-sum-1782813105)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260630141333-4-746863/mk-putuskan-dana-pensiun-tak-harus-dicairkan-berkala-bisa-sekaligus), translated from Indonesian
Print