Constitutional Court Rules Presidential Insult Articles Can Only Be Pursued Upon Direct Complaint by President or Vice President
The Constitutional Court (MK) has narrowed the application of articles concerning the insult of the President and Vice President in the new Criminal Code (KUHP). The court ruled that the offense can only be prosecuted based on a direct complaint from the president or vice president themselves.
In its ruling, the MK partially granted the judicial review petition against Article 220 paragraph (1) of the KUHP. The court declared the article conditionally unconstitutional unless it is interpreted to mean that the criminal act, as referred to in Articles 218 and 219, can only be prosecuted upon a complaint by the president and/or vice president.
Constitutional Justice M. Guntur Hamzah stated that this affirmation is necessary to ensure legal certainty. He explained that the previous phrasing in the new Criminal Code opened a loophole for interpretation, potentially allowing complaints to be represented or initiated by external parties. The court stressed that the legal subjects entitled to lodge a valid complaint are strictly the president and/or vice president. This can be done directly or through a special power of attorney granted to legal counsel.
Guntur added that this legal construction is fundamentally different from the old Criminal Code, where the offense was classified as an ordinary delict, which risked arbitrary enforcement. The affirmation of a pure complaint-based offense is considered to have accommodated a balance between protecting the dignity of state leaders and the constitutional rights of citizens to express their opinions.
However, the MK rejected the petitioners’ request to completely annul Articles 218 and 219 of the KUHP. The court argued that Article 218 paragraph (1) does not solely protect the personal interests of the official but aims to maintain the honor and authority of the presidential institution. Furthermore, Article 218 paragraph (2) functions as a guarantee to prevent excessive application of the protection, while preserving the space for freedom of expression guaranteed by the 1945 Constitution. The judicial review petition was originally filed by a group of 12 university students.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-rules-presidential-insult-articles-can-only-be-pursued-upon-direct-complaint-by-1786557052)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/921242/mk-tegaskan-pasal-penghinaan-presiden-hanya-bisa-dituntut-atas-aduan-langsung-presidenwapres), translated from Indonesian