Constitutional Court Rules Corporate Criminal Liability May Be Cumulative or Alternative
Jakarta (ANTARA) — The Constitutional Court (MK), in decision No. 371/PUU-XXIV/2026, ruled that the word “and” in Article 326(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code is contrary to the 1945 Constitution unless interpreted as “and/or”. This means the wording on corporate criminal liability is both cumulative and alternative.
“According to the Court, it is important to align the wording of Article 326(1) of Law No. 20/2025 (the National Criminal Procedure Code) with Article 49 of Law No. 1/2026 (Criminal Penalty Adjustments), by using a cumulative and alternative formulation — namely, the phrase ‘and/or’ in Article 326(1) of Law No. 20/2025,” Constitutional Justice Daniel Yusmic P. Foekh said, according to a statement from the Court’s Public Relations office in Jakarta on Friday.
The ruling fully upheld a petition for judicial review of Law No. 20/2025 on the Criminal Procedure Code, filed by Andri Yanto, president director of PT Abimanyu Pustaka Utama. The judgment was delivered on Thursday (29 October).
The Court said that using the cumulative and alternative construction “and/or” would allow the parties subject to liability for corporate crime to be identified more appropriately. Liability could be imposed on the corporation alone, the person responsible for the corporation alone, or both the corporation and that individual, depending on the basis for liability.
Daniel said the cumulative and alternative formulation using “and/or” had already been used in Article 362(1) of Law No. 20/2025.
The Court said the provision on sanctions in Article 362(1) of the National Criminal Procedure Code would also promote fairness. In particular, judges could choose to rule against the corporation, its responsible individual, or both, based on the legal facts established at trial.
The Court also stressed that, when implementing Article 326(1), law enforcement authorities must exercise care in deciding whether liability for a corporate crime should be imposed on the corporation alone or its responsible individual alone as an alternative, or on both cumulatively. This, it said, is necessary to achieve fair legal certainty.
The provision under review, Article 362(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code, is in Chapter XVIII on corporations, Section One (General), and states: “Criminal liability for an offence committed by a corporation is imposed on the Corporation and the person responsible for the corporation.”
The petitioner argued that the article violated Articles 28D(1) and 28G(1) of the 1945 Constitution and harmed his constitutional rights, because his position as the person responsible for a corporation could expose him to criminal liability.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-rules-corporate-criminal-liability-may-be-cumulative-or-alternative-1793379079)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5822695/mk-putuskan-pertanggungjawaban-pidana-korporasi-kumulatif-alternatif), translated from Indonesian