Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Constitutional Court Reviews Judicial Law on Ramadan and Shawwal Determination

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Constitutional Court Reviews Judicial Law on Ramadan and Shawwal Determination
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) - The Constitutional Court (MK) held a preliminary hearing on Tuesday regarding the judicial review of the Religious Court Law concerning the verification (isbat) of the start and end of Ramadan.

The preliminary hearing for the judicial review of Law Number 3 of 2006, which amended Law Number 7 of 1989 concerning the Religious Court, took place in the plenary courtroom of Building I of the Constitutional Court in Jakarta.

The petition to review the Religious Court Law regarding the verification of the start and end of Ramadan was filed by Andri Sumarna, Muhammad Fajri Nur Rizky, and Rozak Daud.

The three Muhammadiyah members are challenging Article 52A and its accompanying explanation in the Religious Court Law, which they claim contradicts the 1945 Constitution.

Article 52A of the Religious Court Law states, “The religious court provides verification of hilal (crescent moon) sighting testimony in determining the beginning of months in the Hijri calendar.”

The explanation for Article 5lag states that the Ministry of Religious Affairs requests religious courts to provide legal verification (isbat) for testimonies of those who have witnessed the hilal at the start of Ramadan and Shawwal. This is used by the Minister of Religious Affairs to issue national determinations for the start of 1 Ramadan and 1 Shawwal. Additionally, religious courts may provide information or advice regarding differences in determining the Qibla direction and prayer times.

According to the petitioners, the enforcement of Article 52A and its explanation has caused constitutional loss to those who rely on the ‘hisab’ (astronomical calculation) method to determine the start of Hijri months, including 1 Ramadan, 1 Shawwal, and other religious days.

They argue this loss arises because the explanation grants the Minister of Religious Affairs the authority to set the start of the Hijri months nationally through the mechanism of verifying moon sighting testimonies. The Minister then uses these verifications as the basis for national religious holidays.

The petitioners contend that the construction of this explanation gives the ‘rukyat hilal’ method official state recognition as a national standard, whereas the ‘hisab’ method used by the petitioners does not receive equal recognition. Consequently, their religious practices based on ‘hisab’ face discriminatory treatment and a lack of legal certainty.

Specifically, they cite three issues: first, the restriction to only Ramadan and Shawwal despite the Hijri year consisting of 12 months; second, the introduction of new norms via the phrase regarding the Minister’s national determination; and third, the addition of new authority regarding Qibla and prayer time advice.

“The substantive difference between the body of Article 52A and its explanation creates normative inconsistency,” said Juanda, one of the petitioners’ legal counsel.

He noted that while the main article broadly covers the verification of moon sighting testimonies for all Hijri months, the explanation limits its application to Ramadan and Shawwal and adds powers not found in the primary article. “The explanation of an article should only serve as an official interpretation of the main norm, not as a basis for creating new norms,” he added.

He further argued that an explanation must not expand, narrow, or introduce covert changes to the substance of the law, as adding new norms leads to legal ambiguity and uncertainty.

Constitutional Judge M. Guntur Hamzah advised the petitioners to sharpen their legal standing and strengthen their legal arguments (posita). Constitutional Judge Daniel Yusmic P. Foekh requested that the petitioners carefully align the articles being challenged with their specific prayers (petitum).

Chief Justice Suhartoyo suggested that the petitioners must prove that all Muhammadiyah members strictly follow the ‘hisab’ method and are specifically harmed by the current regulations. “You must demonstrate whether the ‘hisab’ method, and the requirement for religious courts to issue determinations for moon sightings, acts as an actual barrier for the petitioners in performing their worship,” Suhartaryo explained.

More from 10 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-reviews-judicial-law-on-ramadan-and-shawwal-determination-1781031117)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5601507/mk-uji-materi-uu-peradilan-agama-perihal-isbat-awal-dan-akhir-ramadhan), translated from Indonesian
Print