Constitutional Court Rejects Lawsuit by Forest-Fire Victims: Judges Explain Why
Indonesia’s Constitutional Court (MK) rejected a petition for a judicial review of Law No. 24 of 2007 on Disaster Management, filed by four residents of Palangkaraya, Central Kalimantan, affected by forest and land fires.
In Decision No. 369/PUU-XXIV/2026, the Court found that the petitioners’ arguments concerning the phrase ‘adequate’ in provisions on disaster-management funding had no basis in law.
The ruling was delivered by Constitutional Court Justice Liliek Prisbawono Adi during a plenary hearing at Court Building I in Jakarta on Thursday (29 October 2026).
“Accordingly, the petitioners’ argument that the phrase ‘adequate’ in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) of Law No. 24/2007 is unconstitutional in relation to Article 23(1) of the 1945 Constitution is unfounded and must be declared to have no basis in law,” Liliek said.
The petition was filed by Damai Alam Usop, Krismen Sento Shaloho, Davit Purwodsrantau and Paulus Alfons Yance Dhanarto. They challenged the use of the phrase ‘adequate’ in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) of the Disaster Management Law.
The petitioners argued that the absence of objective criteria for determining whether disaster-management funding is sufficient could create legal uncertainty. They also said this could undermine the protection of the right to a healthy environment from the effects of forest and land fires.
In its reasoning, the Court also considered the petitioners’ argument linking the phrase ‘adequate’ to the principle that financial relations between the central and regional governments must be fair and harmonious, as stipulated in Article 18A(2) of the 1945 Constitution.
Liliek explained that the Constitution mandates lawmakers to regulate financial relations between the central government and regional governments.
That mandate has, among other things, been implemented through Law No. 1 of 2022 on Financial Relations between the Central Government and Regional Governments, which regulates transfer and funding mechanisms for regional administrations.
The Court also considered that the petitioners’ request for ‘adequate’ to mean regional budgets (APBD) drawn up ‘professionally in line with the region’s disaster-risk level’ could create new problems.
It said this interpretation could introduce additional criteria, resulting in legal uncertainty while also narrowing the meaning of ‘adequate’ in the law.
The petitioners also highlighted the concentration of forest-fire risks in peatland areas such as Central Kalimantan. They argued that this places an uneven fiscal burden on regions with higher disaster risks.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-rejects-lawsuit-by-forest-fire-victims-judges-explain-why-1793296254)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1939698-gugatan-warga-korban-karhutla-ditolak-mk-ini-alasan-hakim), translated from Indonesian