Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Constitutional Court Rejects Forest-Fire Victims’ Judicial Review Bid, Saying Claims Lack Basis

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Constitutional Court Rejects Forest-Fire Victims’ Judicial Review Bid, Saying Claims Lack Basis
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) — The Constitutional Court has rejected a judicial review petition challenging Law No. 24 of 2007 on Disaster Management, filed by Palangkaraya residents affected by forest and land fires. The Court said the petitioners’ arguments lacked a legal basis.

Petition No. 369/PUU-XXIV/2026 was filed by Damai Alam Usop, Krismen Sento Shaloho, Davit Purwodsrantau and Paulus Alfons Yance Dhanarto. They argued that the phrase “adequate” in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) of the Disaster Management Law was unconstitutional under Article 23(1) of the 1945 Constitution.

Constitutional Court Justice Liliek Prisbawono Adi, reading out the Court’s reasoning at a plenary hearing at the Court’s Building I in Jakarta on Thursday, said the phrase “adequate” in the provisions did not conflict with the 1945 Constitution.

“Accordingly, the petitioners’ argument that the phrase ‘adequate’ in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) of Law No. 24/2007 is unconstitutional under Article 23(1) of the 1945 Constitution is without basis and must be declared legally unfounded,” Liliek said.

Liliek said that, in response to the petitioners’ argument that the phrase “adequate” in Article 8(d) conflicted with the principle of fair and balanced financial relations between the central and regional governments under Article 18A(2) of the Constitution, the Court noted that the provision mandates that such relations be regulated by law.

The legislature had fulfilled that mandate, he said, including through Law No. 1 of 2022 on Financial Relations between the Central Government and Regional Governments, which principally regulates transfer and funding mechanisms for regional governments.

The petitioners asked the Court to interpret “adequate” as requiring regional budgets to be drawn up “professionally, in line with the region’s disaster risk”. The Court said this would create a new parameter that could cause legal uncertainty and narrow the meaning of “adequate” in the provisions.

Liliek added that the petitioners’ argument that forest and land-fire risks are concentrated in peatland areas such as Central Kalimantan Province, creating an increasingly uneven fiscal burden, concerned funding transfers, priorities and implementation. It did not raise a constitutional issue with the phrase “adequate” in Article 8(d) of the Disaster Management Law.

“Accordingly, all of the petitioners’ arguments are legally unfounded,” Liliek said.

The four Palangkaraya residents challenged the phrase “adequate” in Article 6(e) and Article 8(d) of the Disaster Management Law, arguing that the absence of objective criteria for determining sufficient disaster-management funding created legal uncertainty and disregarded guarantees protecting the right to a healthy environment from the effects of forest and land fires.

More from 29 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-rejects-forest-fire-victims-judicial-review-bid-saying-claims-lack-basis-1793292703)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5820583/mk-tolak-uji-materil-warga-terdampak-karhutla-dalil-tidak-berdasar), translated from Indonesian
Print