Constitutional Court Orders Operators to Provide Options Ensuring Unused Internet Quota Remains Active
The Constitutional Court (MK) has partially granted a judicial review petition regarding the forfeiture of internet quota and mandated the availability of service options that guarantee users’ remaining quota remains active and usable. Chief Justice Suhartoyo read the verdict during a ruling hearing in Jakarta on Thursday, stating that petition number 273/PUU-XXIII/2025 was partially granted. “Granting the petitioners’ request in part,” Suhartoyo said.
The MK declared that Article 28 paragraph (1) in Article 71 point 2 of the Appendix to Law Number 6 of 2023 concerning Job Creation is contrary to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and has no conditionally binding legal force as long as it is not interpreted to mean that telecommunications operators are obliged to provide service options that guarantee users’ remaining quota remains active and usable.
In its considerations, Constitutional Justice Adies Kadir stated that telecommunications tariffs must reflect the value of services received by users, including the protection of internet quota that has been paid for but not yet utilised. According to Adies, telecommunications service users who still have remaining quota must receive legal protection for that right, for both prepaid and postpaid services.
The MK stated that this protection can be realised through several service options, such as quota accumulation or rollover, validity period extension, benefit transfer, compensation, refund, or other mechanisms. The court assessed that these service options need to be explicitly regulated to provide legal certainty for telecommunications operators while ensuring fair protection for consumers. “Quota that has not been fully used must remain protected as the property of telecommunications service users or can be used until exhausted without being charged additional fees or tariffs,” Adies said.
The MK also stated that the central government must establish a tariff formula that is adaptive to technological developments, business models, and community needs while prioritising consumer protection. Furthermore, the government and telecommunications operators are requested to involve stakeholders and consumer protection agencies when making tariff adjustments.
The case was filed by online motorcycle taxi driver Didi Supandi and online culinary trader Wahyu Triana Sari, who challenged the provisions of Article 71 point 2 of Law Number 6 of 2023 concerning Job Creation. The petitioners’ legal counsel, Viktor Santoso Tandiasa, stated that the article contained a multi-interpretable norm without limiting parameters, giving operators absolute freedom to conflate service tariffs with ownership duration. This created legal uncertainty for telecommunications service users as consumers because they never knew for certain why data commodities that had been fully paid for could disappear solely due to a unilaterally determined time variable.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-orders-operators-to-provide-options-ensuring-unused-internet-quota-remains-active-1784803875)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/914003/mk-wajibkan-operator-sediakan-layanan-agar-sisa-kuota-internet-tetap-aktif), translated from Indonesian