Constitutional Court Orders Government, BPK, and KPK to Align State Loss Standards
The Constitutional Court (MK) has ordered the Government and a number of law enforcement and financial audit institutions to sit together to align their perceptions regarding the standards and mechanisms for calculating and proving state financial losses. The order was delivered by Chief Justice Suhartoyo during a hearing on the judicial review of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code (KUHP), in Petition Number 206/PUU-XXIV/2026, on Thursday (27/8).
The meeting involves the Government, the Supreme Court (MA), the Audit Board of Indonesia (BPK), the Attorney General’s Office, the Police, the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK), and the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP).
“Including possible options that can be taken and agreed upon, and later within the time determined by the Panel of Judges of 21 working days, the results will be reported through a public hearing,” said Suhartoyo in the hearing at the MK Plenary Courtroom, Jakarta.
Suhartoyo said the meeting would be coordinated by the BPK and must be held within 21 working days from the hearing. The results of the meeting must then be reported to the MK in a hearing on Tuesday, 6 October 2026 at 10.30 WIB. The hearing is scheduled to hear statements from the parties regarding the results of the meeting coordinated by the BPK.
“Hopefully there will no longer be differing perceptions, so that it becomes a unified view and we will hear it in one hearing session on that day,” said Suhartoyo.
Suhartoyo expressed hope that all parties would set aside sectoral interests in the discussion. According to him, the meeting must be directed towards producing a common understanding that can serve as a shared reference.
“I think there should be no sectoral ego; I think it is for the common interest so that later there will be no things that are counterproductive and so on,” he said.
Meanwhile, Deputy Chief Justice Saldi Isra stressed that the discussion does not only concern the standardisation of calculating state financial losses. The parties were also asked to clarify the relationship and authority of each institution that has so far had the authority to conduct audits.
According to Saldi, the position of the BPK also needs to be clearly placed in the inter-institutional relationship with reference to Article 23 of the 1945 Constitution. “Please discuss that in depth so that later it can be reported, and not just if possible, but must be reported to the Court on such matters, and that will later become the basis for us to examine this petition more comprehensively,” explained Saldi.
Petition Number 206/PUU-XXIV/2026 was filed by retired Rear Admiral Leonardi. He is reviewing the phrase “state financial audit institution” in the Elucidation of Article 603 of the Criminal Code.
The petitioner considers that the phrase does not explicitly mention the BPK as the authorised state financial audit institution. This condition is deemed to create norm ambiguity and room for multiple interpretations in determining the institution authorised to examine and calculate state financial losses.
According to the petitioner, this ambiguity has the potential to cause differences in treatment in legal processes. In practice, a person can be criminally processed based on a BPKP audit, while in other cases the calculation of state losses may use the results of a BPK examination, an inspectorate, or other audit institutions.
The petitioner considers this condition creates double standards in proving the element of state financial loss and contradicts the principles of legal certainty and equality before the law.
In his petition, the petitioner asked the MK to declare the Elucidation of Article 603 of the Criminal Code, insofar as the phrase “state financial audit institution” is concerned, contrary to the 1945 Constitution and conditionally not legally binding, insofar as it is not interpreted as “the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia”.
Previously, the MK had heard the main points of the petition and the revised petition, as well as statements from the President/Government, the DPR, the Supreme Court, the BPK, the Attorney General’s Office, the Police, the KPK, and the BPKP. Through this follow-up hearing, the MK asked all parties to bring their views together to formulate clearer standards and mechanisms regarding the calculation and proof of state financial losses.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-orders-government-bpk-and-kpk-to-align-state-loss-standards-1787835055)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/926704/mk-perintahkan-pemerintah-bpk-hingga-kpk-samakan-standar-kerugian-negara), translated from Indonesian