Constitutional Court Judges Question Gibran's Diploma
The Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education has explained the process for the equivalence of overseas education undertaken by Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, as Constitutional Court judges raised questions regarding his diploma.
As background, former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights Denny Indrayana, along with 11 other petitioners, filed lawsuit number 0lar/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026. The preliminary examination hearing for the petition was held at the Constitutional Court on Monday, 21 September.
The respondents in this lawsuit are the General Elections Commission (KPU) of Indonesia, with the General Election Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu) acting as a related party. The petitioners allege that the failure to meet Gibran’s educational requirements only recently came to light and that information regarding this matter was suppressed.
The petitioners stated that if trial evidence proves Gibran meets the educational requirements, the Court may affirm the validity of his candidacy. Conversely, if the evidence shows he does not meet the requirements, the Court must impose disqualification.
The hearing proceeded to the examination process. On Friday, 2 October 2026, the Constitutional Court summoned the Director General of the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education, as well as Education Attachés from the Indonesian Embassies in Australia and Singapore.
Gogot Suharwoto, the Director General of Early Childhood, Primary, and Non-Formal and Informal Education at the Ministry, explained that Gibran’s application for educational equivalence was conducted online on 6 August 2019. He noted that several documents were submitted during the process.
“With your permission, I must clarify that my current position began in 2021, Your Honour. Therefore, we are reading a request from 2019. The submitted learning documents include records from SLTP Negeri 1 Surakarta, Indonesia, Orchid Park Secondary School, Singapore, and UTS Insearch, Australia,” said Gogot.
Gogot stated that the equivalence service team at the time verified the completeness and suitability of the required documents. He mentioned that the document requirements were regulated under Director General Decree Number 30/MPK/D/KS Year 2000, dated 18 January 2018.
The required documents included:
Passport photographs
Passports
Certificates from the local Indonesian representative and/or foreign representatives in Indonesia and/or certificates from the original overseas school
Diplomas/certificates if issued by the educational institution
Academic transcripts
Curriculum structure (not required if available on the school’s official website)
Birth certificate
Report cards for grades 1, 2, and 3 for Junior/Senior High School, or scans of the last 3 years of primary school reports, depending on the proposed equivalence.
Gogot noted that the application files were submitted to an assessment team for verification. He stated that the team assessed the entirety of Gibran’s educational history at Orchid Park Secondary School and UTS Insearch, Australia. He added that Gibran’s educational background was deemed consistent with the accounting and finance specialisation at the Vocational High School (SMK) level in Indonesia.
“Based on the comparison of subjects and learning outcomes or graduation competency standards, the educational history was deemed to be consistent with the accounting and finance specialisation at the Vocational High School (SMK) level,” he said.
He further explained that the assessment results were returned to the equivalence service team at the Secretariat of the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education. Based on the verification, Gibran’s overseas schooling was deemed equivalent to the SMK level in Indonesia.
“The certificate of equivalence was subsequently issued on 6 August 2019, under number 11149/D/D1/KS/2019, signed by the Secretary of the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education. The core content of the letter states that the applicant’s education is equivalent to the accounting and finance specialisation at the SMK level,” he noted.
Gogot remarked that international education systems differ in terms of levels, duration, certificate terminology, and pathways to higher education. He emphasised that the assessment for equivalence was conducted against the entire educational record, including continuity of levels, duration and level of learning, learning outcomes, transcripts, and curriculum structure.
“In the assessment team’s analysis, these documents show that the subject of assessment does not rely on a single specific certificate, but rather on the applicant’s entire educational journey and the continuity of learning across more than one education system. Within this framework, the O-Level certificate is not automatically positioned as an Indonesian High School diploma, but rather as one part of the secondary education record,” he explained.
Gogot stated that the assessment team reviewed Gibran’s continued education at UTS Insearch, Australia, and assessed it as a continuation of secondary education. Subjects at UTS Insearch, Australia—including Accounting, Financial Management, Business Law and Ethics, Marketing, Microeconomics, and Management—were matched or deemed equivalent to the curriculum structure of the accounting and finance vocational programme in Indonesia.
“It can be concluded that based on the comparison of learning outcomes or graduation competency standards, the educational history was deemed consistent with the accounting and finance specialisation at the Vocational High School level,” he concluded.
Judges Question the Diploma
Taufiq Damarjati, a member of the assessment and verification team at the Ministry, explained that they received a certificate of attendance for Gibran from UTS Insearch (now UTS College) in Sydney, Australia. The judges then questioned whether any other certificates had been submitted by Gibran.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-judges-question-gibrans-diploma-1790996041)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8690303/saat-hakim-mk-bertanya-tanya-soal-ijazah-gibran), translated from Indonesian