Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Constitutional Court Judge Rebukes Denny Indrayana's Team for Laughing During Hearing

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Constitutional Court Judge Rebukes Denny Indrayana's Team for Laughing During Hearing
Image: detikcom

Constitutional Court Judge Saldi Isra reprimanded Denny Indrayana’s legal team for displaying excessive reactions by laughing in the Constitutional Court (MK) courtroom. Saldi requested that Denny remind his staff to maintain decorum, warning that they would be asked to leave the courtroom otherwise.

The reprimand was delivered by Saldi Isra during the hearing for the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Result Dispute (PHPU) number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 in Central Jakarta on Wednesday (23/9/2026). At the time, the KPU (General Elections Commission), acting as the Respondent, along with Bawaslu (Election Supervisory Body) and the Gibran 0’8 Nusantara Association as related parties, had completed their responses to the dispute.

MK Chairperson Suhartoyo then invited the constitutional judges to provide notes, starting with Judge Arsul Sani. Arsul requested further clarification regarding the KPU’s response, specifically focusing on the thickness of the submitted documents.

Arsul addressed the KPU’s explanation in point 22 of Article 18 paragraph (1) letter m and Article 18 paragraph (1) of PKPU Number 19 of 2023. This regulation concerns the required documents for candidate pairs, including proof of graduation such as photocopies of diplomas, certificates of completion, or other letters legalised by educational institutions.

Furthermore, the regulation provides an exception for presidential or vice-presidential candidates who do not possess high school graduation proof from foreign schools but do possess university graduation proof. Arsul also referenced point 126 of Article 18 paragraph (3) of PKPU 19/2023, which allows candidates with foreign high school credentials to use university graduation documents.

Arsul linked this to evidence P-20 submitted by the petitioners, specifically Minutes of Meeting Number 1859/PL.01.4-BA/05/2023, regarding the verification of candidate requirement documents on 28 October 2023. He noted that the KPU’s records state they verified the documents for presidential candidate Prabowo Subianto and vice-presidential candidate Gibran Rakabuming Raka, declaring them to meet the necessary requirements.

Arsul requested the KPU to clarify exactly which documents were verified. It was at this moment that Denny Indrayana’s team responded to Arsul’s remarks with laughter.

Arsul expressed hope that the matter would be clarified in future hearings, noting that while he could not predict if further evidence-gathering sessions would occur, the clarification was necessary. He questioned whether the KPU’s verification was limited only to the equivalence letters issued by the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education, which were notably absent from the KPU’s attachments.

He further questioned whether the KPU had verified all documents, such as diplomas, certificates, or awards from schools in Singapore, to ensure a full understanding of the educational levels involved, such as GCE O-Level or A-Level.

Denny’s legal team laughed again when Arsul mentioned having taken a three-week English course at UTS College, an institution of which he is an alumnus.

Arsul emphasised that the KPU needs to clarify whether the pathway programmes in question were matriculation, foundation, or other types of programmes to ensure clarity.

Arsul concluded his notes by quoting Surah Ali ’Imran, verse 13, which tells of the signs of God’s power and the victory of Muslims in the Battle of Badr. He stated that regardless of the implications for the Vice President, such matters must serve as a lesson for the future of Indonesian democracy.

More from 23 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-judge-rebukes-denny-indrayanas-team-for-laughing-during-hearing-1790182582)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8676417/hakim-saldi-isra-tegur-tim-denny-indrayana-gegara-ketawa-di-sidang-mk), translated from Indonesian
Print