Constitutional Court Judge Finds Gibran's 'Knowledge Equivalent to Vocational School' Letter Ambiguous
The Constitutional Court (MK) is set to deliver its verdict tonight regarding the dispute over the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election results, specifically concerning the educational requirements of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka. In a previous hearing, MK judges described Gibran’s educational equivalence as ‘ambiguous’ because the equivalence applied to knowledge rather than the diploma itself.
According to the court minutes from Tuesday (6/10/2026), MK judge Arsul Sani highlighted issues regarding the equivalence process conducted by the Ministry of Education and Culture (now the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education) in 2019 for Gibran’s studies abroad. Arsul noted that in 2019, both the Ministry of Education and Culture and the Ministry of Research, Technology, and Higher Education held the authority to issue equivalence letters for overseas education, yet the documents issued by these two institutions were not equal in nature.
“These are two different institutions, two ministries, managing education—one for Primary and Secondary Education, and one for Higher Education—issuing statements that are not equivalent. The equivalence letters are not equal, even though they share the same title. Perhaps the one from the Ministry of Research, Technology, and Higher Education is easier to understand, because what is being equated, even though it is in the form of a decision, is the diploma. Therefore, the title of the decision is regarding the Result of Assessment for Diploma Equivalence of Overseas University Graduates in the name of Gibran Rakabuming Raka,” Arsul stated.
He argued that the letter issued by the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education in 2019 was ambiguous because it equated Gibran’s knowledge rather than the actual diploma obtained from the overseas school, making it difficult for the court to interpret. “This is issued by the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education. To be honest, it is somewhat ambiguous for us to understand. Where is the ambiguity? It is because what you are equating is the knowledge; the individual is assessed as having knowledge equivalent to a vocational high school graduate,” Arsul said.
Arsul mentioned that the Ministry’s actions have caused confusion for the General Elections Commission (KPU). He referenced Ministry of Education Regulation Number 29 of 2014, which stipulates that equivalence should refer to diplomas, certificates, or credentials obtained from overseas educational institutions. “What is being equated is the knowledge. It is assessed as having knowledge equivalent to a school graduate. This is somewhat abstract. If the other type of letter were issued, it would be easy to know: what is equivalent? The diploma. But here, what is equivalent is the knowledge,” he added.
In response during the hearing, the Director General of Primary and Secondary Education, Gogot Suharwoto, provided an explanation. He stated that Gibran had applied for the equivalence of a ‘Diploma of Business Studies’ from UTS Insearch, Australia, a programme that does not exist within the Indonesian education system. “The case we are facing is not about high school; it is a diploma. The course submitted by Gibran Rakabuming Raka is a Diploma of Business Studies which we do not have in Indonesia. It is a case where high school students take subjects at a university level. Therefore, we cannot simply match it; it does not exist,” he explained.
Gogot further explained that this situation meant the equivalence process could not rely solely on the diploma. Instead, the assessment was based on the specific subjects Gibran had completed abroad. “To add to what Mr Arsul said, what was received was a certificate of attendance. What we did was match the subjects taken to ensure they covered a full range of secondary education—at least three years or six semesters—and that the subjects aligned with the specialisations available in Indonesian vocational schools (SMK). That is what we matched.
“Specifically, we matched three elements: the years of study, the academic reports, and the curriculum structure taken in Australia with the curriculum structure of Indonesian vocational schools, specifically in the accounting and finance major,” Gogot concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-judge-finds-gibrans-knowledge-equivalent-to-vocational-school-letter-ambiguous-1791266362)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8694519/momen-hakim-mk-anggap-surat-pengetahuan-setara-tamat-smk-gibran-bersayap), translated from Indonesian