Constitutional Court holds judicial review of new Criminal Procedure Code regarding pre-trial proceedings
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The Constitutional Court (MK) held a preliminary hearing on Wednesday to conduct a judicial review of Law Number 20 of 2025 regarding the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP), specifically questioning matters related to pre-trial proceedings.
In a panel session led by Constitutional Judge Enny Nurbaningsih, accompanied by Asrul Sani and Ridwan Mansur, the petitioner, Maret Samuel Sueke, presented arguments through legal counsel regarding petition number 316/PUU-XXIV/2026.
The petitioner is challenging the absence of a clear time limit for the suspension of substantive case examinations while pre-trial proceedings are ongoing, as stipulated in Article 163, paragraph (1), point e of the new KUHAP.
Legal counsel for the petitioner, Emiral Rangga Trengumento, explained that the petitioner is the reporter in a criminal case based on report LP/B/976/V/2025/SPKT.SATRESKRIM/RESKO BEKASI KOTA/Polda Metro Jaya dated 5 June 2025 (the reported party being Roy Suryo).
He explained that four consecutive pre-trial motions have been filed regarding the case in question.
“The delay in the examination of the substantive case experienced by the petitioner is not caused by the negligence of investigators, prosecutors, or the court, but solely due to the imperative command of the norm in question, which prohibits the examination of the substantive case until the pre-trial examination is completed,” said Emiral.
Constitutional Judge Enny Nurbaningsih requested that the petitioner further elaborate on the nature of the actual constitutional loss suffered.
She also questioned which specific norms are deemed to conflict with the 1945 Constitution within the arguments presented for the judicial review.
In his judicial advice, Constitutional Judge Arsul Sani noted that the petitioner’s application does not yet meet the provisions of MK Regulation (PMK) Number 7 regarding the procedures for judicial review of laws.
“You have not referenced PMK Number 7 of 2025. If you look at examples of previous rulings, the ‘statement of facts’ section should ideally be considered complete,” he remarked.
Before adjourning the session, Judge Enny informed the petitioner that they have 14 days to amend their petition.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-holds-judicial-review-of-new-criminal-procedure-code-regarding-pre-trial-proceedings-1788371744)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5723413/mk-uji-materiil-kuhap-baru-menyoal-praperadilan), translated from Indonesian