Constitutional Court corrects wording of Article 215 of the National Criminal Procedure Code
Jakarta (ANTARA) – A panel of Constitutional Court judges has partly granted a petition for a judicial review of Article 215 of Law No. 20 of 2025 on the National Criminal Procedure Code, correcting the wording by replacing “Expert” in the provision with “Witness”.
In the court’s reasoning, read out by Constitutional Justice M. Guntur Hamzah, the word “Expert” in the article was found to be contrary to the right to develop oneself guaranteed by Article 28C(1) of the 1945 Constitution, as argued by the petitioner.
“However, because the Court’s position is not as requested by the petitioner, the petitioner’s argument is legally well-founded in part,” Guntur said at the verdict hearing in the main courtroom of the Constitutional Court building in Jakarta on Thursday.
In petition No. 383/PUU-XXIV/2026, the petitioner, Dicky Saputra, a student at Sunan Kalijaga State Islamic University in Yogyakarta, challenged the punctuation in the phrase “Witness Expert, or Defendant” in Article 215 of the National Criminal Procedure Code.
Article 215 of the 2025 Code states: “Leading questions may not be put to a Witness Expert, or Defendant.”
The petitioner argued that the comma in the challenged phrase appears only after “Witness Expert”, while there is no punctuation separating “Witness” and “Expert”. Under Indonesian grammar, commas are used to separate items in a list.
On this reading, the ban on leading questions applied only to two categories: expert witnesses and defendants. Ordinary witnesses—people who have heard, seen, experienced or otherwise known about a criminal event—were no longer included among those protected.
The petitioner said that a narrow interpretation of Article 215 could remove witnesses’ protection from leading questions. The legislature had never stated, either in discussions known to the petitioner or in materials available to them, any compelling reason for withholding such protection from witnesses.
The petitioner also argued that Article 215 violated Article 5(f) of Law No. 12 of 2011 on the Formation of Laws and Regulations, which requires clear wording. Legislation, the provision says, must use clear and readily understandable language and terminology so that it does not give rise to differing interpretations in its application.
In its legal reasoning, the Court said Article 215 of the 2025 Code contains the phrase “Witness Expert”, although the Code does not otherwise recognise “expert witness” as a legal category. The phrase appears only in Article 215.
The Court said that a grammatical reading of Article 166 of the previous Criminal Procedure Code and its explanatory notes found no use of the phrase “expert witness”. Article 215 of the National Code uses the phrase, but its explanatory notes do not mention experts or a ban on asking leading questions of experts in court.
“In doctrine, there is a distinction between the meanings of a witness and an expert,” Hamzah said.
The Court held that the ban on leading questions is intended to apply to witnesses or defendants. The phrase “Witness Expert” in Article 215 is therefore inaccurate and could cause confusion and legal uncertainty.
To provide legal certainty, the word “Expert” should be removed from Article 215. The Court added that retaining it would be inconsistent with the article’s explanatory notes and would break its historical connection with Article 166 of the former Code and its explanation.
“The ruling is as follows: the Court grants the petitioner’s application in part,” Constitutional Court Chief Justice Suhartoyo said.
The Court also ruled that the word “Expert” in Article 215 of the National Criminal Procedure Code (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia 2025 No. 188, Supplement to the State Gazette No. 7149) is contrary to the 1945 Constitution and has no binding legal force.
Article 215 will therefore read in full: “Leading questions may not be put to a Witness or Defendant.”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-corrects-wording-of-article-215-of-the-national-criminal-procedure-code-1794484574)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5849643/mk-perbaiki-redaksional-normal-pasal-215-kuhap-nasional), translated from Indonesian