Constitutional Court Cannot Disqualify Gibran; Who Holds the Authority to Determine the Vice President's Fate?
The Constitutional Court (MK) has revealed significant findings regarding the educational documents of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka in a case questioning his eligibility requirements for the 2024 Presidential Election. During the trial, the Court stated it found no convincing evidence, such as overseas diplomas, certificates, or degrees, that could serve as a basis for equating Gibran’s education to a high school level or equivalent.
Nevertheless, these findings do not automatically alter Gibran’s position as Vice President. The Constitutional Court emphasised that it cannot disqualify Gibran because the submitted case is no longer appropriately placed within the regime for resolving presidential election result disputes.
This raises the question: who possesses the authority to assess the validity and fulfillment of the requirements for presidential and vice-presidential candidates?
During the verdict session for Case Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 at the Constitutional Court Building in Jakarta on Tuesday night (6/10/2026), Constitutional Judge Adies Kadir explained that such matters fall under the jurisdiction of other institutions authorised by the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
“Substantially, this falls within the domain of institutions that have the authority to assess the validity and fulfillment of the requirements for presidential and vice-presidential candidates as regulated in the 1945 Constitution,” he stated.
In its considerations, the Court stated it did not find or obtain convincing evidence that Gibran possesses any overseas diplomas, certificates, or degrees that could serve as a basis for equivalence to a minimum of high school education, as stipulated in Article 169 letter r and Article 227 letter l of the Election Law.
However, these findings do not provide a basis for the Court to annul or disqualify Gibran. Adies explained that Gibran’s status as a vice-presidential candidate concluded once he was inaugurated and sworn in as Vice President on 20 October 2024.
“The Court cannot annul or disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka in his position as Vice President, as requested in the Petitioners’ prayer,” said Constitutional Judge Adies Kadir during the verdict announcement for the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Result Dispute at the Constitutional Court of Indonesia in Jakarta on Tuesday night.
According to the Court, the inauguration of the elected pair simultaneously marks the end of the 2024 Presidential Election stages. Consequently, issues regarding Gibran’s candidacy requirements can no longer be examined through the mechanism of presidential election result disputes.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-cannot-disqualify-gibran-who-holds-the-authority-to-determine-the-vice-presidents-fate-1791348869)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1933870-gibran-tak-bisa-didiskualifikasi-mk-siapa-yang-berwenang-tentukan-nasib-wapres), translated from Indonesian