Constitutional Court Affirms Freedom of Expression as a Constitutional Right That Must Be Protected
The Constitutional Court (MK) has annulled Article 240 and Article 241 of Law Number 1 of 2023. The court assessed that these articles could pose a threat of criminalisation over criticism and evaluation directed at state institutions.
This was conveyed by the MK during the reading of Decision Number 282/PUU-XXIII/2025, held on Friday (28/8/2026) in the Plenary Courtroom of the MK Building, Central Jakarta. The MK declared both articles to be in conflict with the Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
“Granting the Petitioners’ request in its entirety,” said Chief Justice Suhartoyo when reading the decision.
“Declaring Article 240 and the Elucidation of Article 240 of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code to be in conflict with the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and to have no binding legal force. Declaring Article 241 of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code to be in conflict with the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and to have no binding legal force,” he continued.
In its considerations, the MK assessed that the norms of Article 240 and Article 241 of Law 1/2023 could eliminate citizens’ rights to express opinions. This is because both articles place state institutions such as the MPR, DPR, DPD, Supreme Court, and Constitutional Court as protected objects.
“Whereas within the limits of reasonable reasoning, all institutions, including state institutions, are legal subjects that do not possess feelings, whether feelings of being praised, feelings of being reproached, or feelings of being insulted,” said Constitutional Justice Adies Kadir during the session.
According to the MK, if one wishes to safeguard the dignity of a state institution, then it is the people within that state institution who must uphold the dignity or honour of the institution itself. To safeguard the dignity of state institutions, the MK stated that individuals must carry out the duties and functions of their respective institutions in accordance with the purpose of their establishment.
The MK held the view that if someone expresses an opinion to a state institution, this must be guaranteed by the state.
“The Court declares that the guarantee of the right to express thoughts and attitudes in accordance with one’s conscience and to express opinions is a right that must be safeguarded and protected as guaranteed in the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. Without such a guarantee, the fulfilment of human rights, including other civil liberties, becomes threatened and will lose its true meaning,” it stated.
Therefore, the MK assessed that the petitioners’ claim that the norms of Article 240 and Article 241 of Law 1/2023 were legally grounded. The petitioners considered that these two articles could create a threat of criminalisation over legitimate criticism, evaluation, and opinion, and could produce a frightening effect or chilling effect on society in expressing thoughts and attitudes openly, causing violations of human rights as guaranteed in the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
For information, this petition was filed by Tania Iskandar (Petitioner I), Sila Fide Novira Nggebu (Petitioner II), Muhammad Restu (Petitioner III), Yuni Wulan Ningsih (Petitioner IV), Ika Minawati (Petitioner V), Putra Muhamad Fadilla (Petitioner VI), Tasya Ayu Hapsari (Petitioner VII), Mawar Prasiska Nur Rizki (Petitioner VIII), and Riesa Zhafirah (Petitioner IX).
The Petitioners stated that with the entry into force of Article 240 of the Criminal Code, they were directly placed in a vulnerable position regarding restrictions and criminalisation of the exercise of their constitutional rights. This is because the existence of the phrase “insulting the government or state institutions” in the article in question does not provide a clear definition or objective parameter. It thus opens up broad and subjective room for interpretation, particularly regarding the difference between criticism, academic assessment, and political expression, and acts categorised as “insult”.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-court-affirms-freedom-of-expression-as-a-constitutional-right-that-must-be-protected-1787971881)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8639088/mk-tegaskan-kebebasan-berpendapat-hak-konstitusional-yang-wajib-dilindungi), translated from Indonesian