Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Confusing signals

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Confusing signals

The economic stabilization and reform program which President
B.J. Habibie elaborated in his first Independence Day address
last week indicates the right path toward the kind of market
economy suitable for an Indonesian civil society in the future.
Although almost nothing is new in the program -- most of the
measures, right down to their sequencing priority, are precisely
the core elements of the IMF-arranged bailout program for the
country -- it could still convey the right signal to the market.
It seems to reconfirm that the present government has fully
realized, and would thus guard against repeating, the grave
mistakes of the preceding Soeharto regime that have caused the
current economic crisis.

Habibie talked about the need for healthy competition by
abolishing monopolies, special treatment, exclusive permits and
business rights and other antimarket measures. He reemphasized
the importance of good public and corporate governance as well as
a strong banking industry as the main artery of the economy's
lifeblood.

But this good concept is only a statement of intentions,
wishes and ideals which will mean nothing without implementation,
and a very consistent one for that matter.

There are no shortcuts to credibility, the main prerequisite
to regaining market confidence which Indonesia lost in the impact
of a complex web of social, economic, political and security
turmoil over the past eight months.

Unfortunately, while the implementation of the program is
still in its early stages after several false starts, the
government often undermines the process with inconsistencies in
actions. Official statements by Habibie and several members of
his Cabinet, meant to provide the operational references based on
the grand macroeconomic concept, instead often throw out
confusing signals to the market.

Pressured by competing demands caused by the economic crisis,
the Habibie administration sometimes gives the impression it is
already geared up for reelection next May. It seems to be
concerned more with the short-term political costs of its policy
actions, as indicated, among other things, by its overemphasis on
populist, yet unsustainable, programs, at the expense of the
long-term foundations of the economy.

Habibie's recent remarks about the urgent need for the
redistribution of economic assets to enhance equity and broaden
the middle class sparked a lot of questions. Equally confusing is
his statement about a new development paradigm based on economic
democracy, dignity and self-reliance. We ourselves cannot
comprehend what he meant, let alone foreign investors.

His chief economics minister, Ginandjar Kartasasmita, asserted
the government would no longer give special protection and
facilities to big business. And the policy actions of the
minister of cooperatives to transfer, by decree, the distribution
system of essential commodities mostly to cooperatives implies as
if other enterprises already well-established within the
distribution chain are merely profiteers.

These statements and actions no doubt are worrying
businesspeople, especially as they were made by policymakers who
have long been perceived as champions of narrow-minded
nationalist economy. The lack of clearly defined details in the
policy statements further stirred fears that the Habibie
administration, pressured over the issue of income inequality, is
highly vulnerable to repeating the mistakes of the Soeharto
regime.

The inconsistencies smack of the old ploy which former
president Soeharto played up any time he encountered criticism of
the income inequality brought about by his economic policies.
Soeharto's jawboning of big businesses in early 1990 to sell up
to 20 percent of their shares to cooperatives at their par value
failed entirely to empower cooperatives.

Yet more worrisome is the tendency among some business
leaders, including Aburizal Bakrie, the chairman of the
Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, to extend the
nationalist-economy concept to its extreme. Aburizal, for
example, has demanded that indigenous businesspeople be given
special privileges and big corporations be obliged to sell at
least 20 percent of their shares to indigenous investors.

While equitable distribution of income must always be enhanced
to sustain economic growth under social and political stability,
asset redistribution or special privileges are by no means an
effective way of achieving that objective.

The evidence is too clear for everyone to see how the huge
government investment in cooperatives and the captive market
granted them for several commodities over the past 25 years
failed to build up strong, efficient and well-managed
cooperatives in the business sector. Now Minister of Cooperatives
Adi Sasono is taking a big risk of making a similar mistake by
pouring trillion of rupiah and providing special privileges to
cooperatives.

Habibie and his Cabinet, if they are really serious about
gaining credibility and winning back market confidence, need to
work more persistently to practice what they preach in order to
convince the public that what they are doing is not aimed mainly
for positioning for the May general election, but truly for
stabilizing and laying stronger foundations for the long-term
good of the economy.

More from 20 August 1998 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/confusing-signals-1447893297-1404403)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print