Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Commuter Train Riders Trade Snide Remarks in Crowded Carriages: ‘Don’t Push If There’s No Room’

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Commuter Train Riders Trade Snide Remarks in Crowded Carriages: ‘Don’t Push If There’s No Room’
Image: detikcom

The number of people using the Greater Jakarta commuter rail (KRL) continues to rise, leaving passengers frequently packed into carriages.

Crowding is common during rush hour, when people travel to work in the morning and return home in the evening. At such times, KRL riders—known as anker—often make pointed remarks.

Elsa, 26, a KRL passenger, said she regularly hears such comments while travelling at busy times. She uses the Bekasi line, also known as the Blue Line, and is familiar with the offhand remarks made by other passengers.

She said passengers tend to blurt out comments when carriages are packed during peak hours. The remarks she commonly hears concern people pushing to get on or off, those who do not give up priority seats, and passengers pretending to be asleep.

“During rush hour it’s really crowded. People often make comments and complain. More often, it’s about people refusing to give up their seats to older passengers; lots of people pretend to be asleep too,” Elsa said at Tanah Abang Station on Friday (6 November 2026).

Elsa said many commuters try to barge their way through. She added that passengers are often squeezed and pushed while standing in the train.

“Lots of people just push through. You hear things like, ‘Don’t push, I’m being crushed.’ But it’s crowded, and it gets hot too. When you’re standing, people often push you; you hear, ‘Don’t stand so close,’” she said.

Elsa recalled several of the remarks commuters make, including comments about someone’s body odour.

“‘Stop pushing, or just get out if there’s no room,’ or, ‘Can you move over? You stink.’ You hear that sort of thing. People are tired after work, but often nobody wants to give way,” she said.

Another passenger, Anisa, 20, said she had experienced this while travelling home from work in a women-only carriage. She described the passengers there as very frank.

“It happened when I was going home from work. I was in the women’s carriage, where people tend to speak their minds,” Anisa said.

She recalled a commotion in the carriage when it was already full, but someone still tried to force their way in and ended up calling for help after getting stuck.

“It got chaotic in the women’s carriage because it was completely full, but someone still tried to get in. The person at the back shouted, ‘Help… help… I’m stuck,’” she said.

Anisa said she tends to stay quiet on the train, although she grumbles to herself when it gets crowded.

“I’m the type to stay quiet—quietly grumbling to myself,” she said.

Friction between KRL passengers sometimes escalates into fights. In one recent incident, two passengers exchanged blows at Duri Station after bumping into each other on Wednesday afternoon (4 November).

KAI Commuter has urged all passengers to prioritise safety, avoid causing disturbances and show respect for one another.

More from 6 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/commuter-train-riders-trade-snide-remarks-in-crowded-carriages-dont-push-if-theres-no-room-1793958677)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8741412/asbun-para-anker-saat-berdesakan-di-krl-jangan-dorong-hingga-gak-muat), translated from Indonesian
Print