Commission VIII: East Java MUI Fatwa on 'Sound Horeg' is Appropriate, Does Not Automatically Prohibit It
Maman Imanulhaq, a member of Commission VIII of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI), believes that the issue of ‘sound horeg’ (high-decibel mobile sound systems) should not be limited to debates over whether it is permissible or forbidden. According to him, the more important task is to establish regulations capable of preserving community expression while simultaneously protecting citizens’ rights to peace, security, and safety.
Maman assessed that the East Java Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) fatwa regarding the use of ‘sound horeg’ is appropriate. “The MUI fatwa regarding the prohibition of ‘sound horeg’ is, in my view, correct. It is the duty of the MUI after receiving input and complaints from members of the public who feel disturbed or harmed by certain ‘sound horeg’ practices,” Maman stated in a briefing to Republika on Thursday (10/09/2026).
He noted that the fatwa serves as a response to public grievances regarding specific practices. “The important thing is that the fatwa must be read in its entirety. The MUI is not automatically declaring ‘sound horeg’ as a form of community expression and creativity to be forbidden,” he said.
He explained that the core issue within the fatwa lies in practices that cause disturbances, harm, threaten public order, or disadvantage the community. This includes instances involving the consumption of alcohol or erotic dancing.
Consequently, Maman views the MUI’s stance as a moderate approach. On one hand, community expression and creativity are respected; on the other hand, there is a limit when such expression begins to cause harm to others.
Maman added that the aspirations of ‘sound horeg’ practitioners, who desire regulation rather than a total ban, are logical. The ‘sound horeg’ phenomenon grows from community creativity and expands due to market demand.
“Sound horeg has created a space for expression, opened up employment opportunities, and stimulated the local economy. A phenomenon like this should not be viewed solely as something that must be suppressed,” he said.
Nevertheless, Maman warned that the development of ‘sound horeg’ must not ignore the potential problems that arise when practices become uncontrolled. Excessive volume, public disturbance, issues of public order, potential for unrest, and safety threats must be taken seriously. “This is where the government must step in,” he concluded.