Commercial Court Overturns KPPU Ruling on Online Loan Interest Rates
Jakarta (ANTARA) — A panel of judges at the Commercial Court of the Central Jakarta District Court has overturned a ruling by the Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) concerning interest rates on online loans, or pinjol.
Central Jakarta District Court spokesperson Sunoto said the ruling concerned 97 business entities that had brought legal challenges against the KPPU.
“The verdict was delivered in an open court hearing on Thursday, 22 October 2026, by presiding judge Anton Rizal Setiawan, with Achmad Rasyid Purba and Arief Adikusumo as members of the panel,” Sunoto said when contacted in Jakarta on Saturday.
Following the reversal, the Commercial Court ordered the KPPU to pay court costs of Rp23.59 million.
In case number 05/KPPU-I/2025, the KPPU had found 97 online loan providers, or peer-to-peer (P2P) lending fintech firms, guilty of violating Article 5 of Law No. 5 of 1999 on the prohibition of monopolistic practices and unfair business competition, in connection with setting an upper limit on interest rates.
The KPPU imposed fines totalling Rp755 billion on the 97 business entities.
Sunoto said the judges considered four grounds when overturning the KPPU ruling.
First, the panel considered that the basis for setting the limit was guidance from the Financial Services Authority (OJK). The OJK had issued guidance, including on the interest-rate ceiling, meaning the cap formed part of the state action doctrine, he said.
Second, the panel considered the distinction between a price ceiling and price-fixing. It found that setting a maximum price was not legally prohibited and differed from price-fixing.
Sunoto said the judges considered that the cap instead protected consumers and the public from business operators exercising undue discretion in setting loan interest rates. Providers remained free to set rates for customers as long as they did not exceed the prescribed ceiling.
“The panel considers that there are business operators supplying goods and/or services that are not the same, similar or substitutes for those goods and/or services,” he said.
As conventional and sharia markets were not the same or similar and could not substitute for one another, the judges considered that the requirements for defining the relevant market had not been met, Sunoto said.
The fourth ground concerned an agreement. On this point, the panel found no agreement among the business operators, as they had instead been “forced” to comply with guidelines issued by the Indonesian Joint Funding Fintech Association (AFPI).
Not all 97 online loan companies had participated in drawing up the AFPI guidelines, which were backed by the threat of sanctions for non-compliance.
Sunoto added that the judges hoped state institutions would coordinate effectively when formulating policies, to prevent conflicts between government bodies and support good governance.
“The panel emphasises that business operators cannot be punished for following the guidance of the state authority that supervises them,” Sunoto said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/commercial-court-overturns-kppu-ruling-on-online-loan-interest-rates-1792835566)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5809379/pengadilan-niaga-batalkan-putusan-kppu-soal-bunga-pinjol), translated from Indonesian