Coal Stocks More Resilient to MSCI Shock; Indo Premier Picks AADI and PTBA
KONTAN.CO.ID – JAKARTA. Thermal coal shares are considered more resilient to pressure on the Indonesian stock market following MSCI’s announcement than a number of other commodity stocks. Alongside support from still-high coal prices and the prospect of attractive dividend returns, the group has relatively low foreign investor ownership, which is seen as offering greater protection from the risk of foreign capital outflows.
Indo Premier Sekuritas analyst Ryan Winipta said thermal coal stocks, including PT Adaro Andalan Indonesia Tbk (AADI), PT Bukit Asam Tbk (PTBA), PT United Tractors Tbk (UNTR) and PT Indo Tambangraya Megah Tbk (ITMG), had fallen by only around 10%.
That decline was relatively limited compared with the 9%–21% drop across the commodities sector as a whole after the MSCI announcement, and the 15% fall in the Jakarta Composite Index (JCI).
Second, several companies offer attractive dividend yields. AADI has an estimated dividend yield of 11%, while PTBA’s is around 7%.
Third, thermal coal prices remain high. The Indonesian Coal Index (ICI) benchmark has risen by around 37%–74% year to date and continues to increase week on week, amid coal restocking activity ahead of the winter season.
Given this combination of factors, Indo Premier remains positive on thermal coal stocks, naming AADI and PTBA as its top picks in the sector.
Stocks with high foreign ownership
By contrast, stocks with a high proportion of foreign investor ownership are considered more vulnerable to pressure if global investors begin reducing their exposure to the Indonesian market ahead of MSCI’s decision.
Among the stocks covered by Indo Premier’s analysis, UNTR has the highest foreign fund ownership relative to its free float, at 64%. PT AKR Corporindo Tbk (AKRA) follows at 51%, and PT Aneka Tambang Tbk (ANTM) at 48%.
Ryan said the high level of foreign ownership could prompt active foreign investors to sell early ahead of the MSCI announcement, which is expected in June 2027.
In terms of MSCI indices, UNTR is currently the only commodity stock in Indo Premier’s coverage that is a constituent of the MSCI Standard Index. MDKA, ADRO, AADI, PGAS, PTBA, AKRA and INCO are members of the MSCI Small Cap Index.
Index decisions are usually implemented around three to six months after they are made. As a result, short-term pressure is more likely to come from active foreign investors pre-emptively reducing their holdings before an official decision is announced.
Ryan added that stocks with high foreign ownership could also recover more quickly than high-dividend shares if foreign outflows stabilise or Indonesia is not downgraded to Standalone Market status by MSCI.
Alongside foreign ownership, investors should consider companies’ financial structures amid market uncertainty.
Indo Premier noted that ESSA and ITMG have the highest net cash-to-market capitalisation ratios in its coverage, at 45% each. In contrast, MDKA, PT Medco Energi Internasional Tbk (MEDC) and PT Harum Energy Tbk (HRUM) have the highest net debt-to-market capitalisation ratios.
According to Ryan, companies with substantial net debt are more vulnerable to rising costs of capital over the long term.
However, debt levels should be assessed in light of each company’s business characteristics. MEDC, for example, naturally requires more financing because it operates in oil and gas exploration and production (E&P), a sector that generally requires significant capital investment.
Overweight recommendation maintained
Despite continued pressure on the outlook for the Indonesian stock market, Indo Premier is maintaining its overweight recommendation on the commodities sector. This reflects its view that the sector could outperform the JCI overall.
Ryan said commodity stocks have an advantage because some of their revenue is earned in US dollars. This can provide support if the rupiah weakens, although the ultimate impact depends on each company’s cost structure and foreign currency exposure.
In addition to thermal coal shares, Indo Premier sees opportunities in several commodity stocks that have fallen sharply despite offering high dividend yields.
According to the securities firm’s sensitivity analysis, PGAS, ANTM and PT Timah Tbk (TINS) are among the stocks that have come under considerable market pressure. Yet all three have estimated dividend yields of more than 10%.
This is seen as creating an accumulation opportunity for investors who consider valuation, dividend potential and market risk together.
Overall, Indo Premier’s strategy is to prioritise high-dividend stocks while remaining alert to foreign ownership and debt risks. AADI and PTBA are its top picks among thermal coal shares, while PGAS, ANTM and TINS merit attention after their sharp declines.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/coal-stocks-more-resilient-to-msci-shock-indo-premier-picks-aadi-and-ptba-1792515021)
Originally published by investasi.kontan.co.id (https://investasi.kontan.co.id/news/saham-batubara-lebih-tahan-guncangan-msci-indo-premier-jagokan-saham-aadi-dan-ptba), translated from Indonesian