Climate Justice and Forest and Land Fires in Indonesia
Climate change can no longer be viewed merely as an ecological anomaly; it has become a multidimensional existential crisis threatening the foundations of human civilisation. In Indonesia, this threat is clearly manifested in recurring ecological disasters in the form of forest and land fires, which intensify during the dry season through a combination of climate anomalies and the El Niño phenomenon.
Although scientific evidence continues to provide alarming data on rising global temperatures and extreme weather, institutional responses are often disproportionate to the scale of the threat. This impasse compels us to shift our analytical lens beyond atmospheric physics and towards a critical examination of the political structures, free-market capitalist economy and extractive model that currently shape the global and national order.
In understanding the roots of this impasse, the central argument made by thinkers such as Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor (2026)—that there is a fundamental clash between the free-market capitalist economic model and planetary boundaries—is highly relevant. An economic system driven by privatisation, deregulation and relentless extraction is inherently incompatible with efforts to reduce carbon emissions.
In Indonesia, this is clearly reflected in human intervention across millions of hectares of peatland ecosystems—in Sumatra, Kalimantan and Papua—to establish concessions and cultivate crops. Draining and canalising peatlands transforms their natural function as permanently waterlogged areas into accumulations of organic fuel that are highly flammable.
Scientifically, the Earth’s ecosystems and peatlands operate through sensitive mechanisms that approach critical thresholds, or tipping points. Dr Elham Sumarga, an ecologist at the School of Life Sciences and Technology at the Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB), explains that peat fires do not burn only on the surface but also below ground, where subsurface smouldering consumes thick organic layers, is extremely difficult to extinguish and triggers dense transboundary haze.
The damage to drained ecosystems is extremely difficult to reverse. Exposure to oxygen accelerates microbial decomposition and causes land subsidence, creating a risk of permanent flooding over the next 50 to 100 years. This biophysical reality clashes sharply with the neoliberal economic fiction that environmental damage can always be remedied through market-based technological innovation.
Unfortunately, policy responses have often been trapped in the illusion of “green capitalism” and false solutions such as carbon trading or emissions offsetting, which serve as greenwashing to preserve the status quo of extractive industries. At the local level, approaches to tackling forest and land fires are often piecemeal and fail to address the overall governance of permits. Yet carbon emissions from these fires are enormous: one hectare of burnt peatland can release around 200 to 300 tonnes of carbon into the atmosphere, directly accelerating global warming and worsening Indonesia’s extreme El Niño and La Niña cycles.
More worryingly, the international and domestic political landscape amid calls for an energy transition is marked by the resurgence of narrow nationalism and sectoral self-interest. Rather than forging inclusive global collaboration, national leaders often prioritise short-term economic growth and the security of fossil-fuel supplies over climate mitigation commitments.
In the absence of solidarity, we are witnessing “disaster capitalism”, in which crises and ecological disasters are often exploited by political elites and corporations to advance privatisation and weaken environmental regulations, while vulnerable communities bear the heaviest burden of health impacts from PM2.5 particulates and the destruction of their livelihoods.
In confronting this complex impasse, modern science shows that incremental reform is no longer adequate; structural transformation is needed. Based on scientific recommendations for environmental governance, efforts to mitigate forest and land fires and climate change in Indonesia must be grounded in ecosystem restoration through rewetting, using canal blocks to maintain peat moisture.
In addition, spatial and hydrological modelling is essential to assess anticipatory policy scenarios, such as a moratorium on new concessions on peatlands more than three metres deep, ending fossil-fuel subsidies, and firmly enforcing the law against the use of fire to clear land.
To align ecological protection with communities’ economic needs, the transition to a regenerative economy could be advanced through flood-tolerant cultivation, or paludiculture, including the planting of sago and purun grass, or the use of jelutung trees. Given political leaders’ reluctance to take drastic measures that could harm large corporations, the driving force for this transformation must come from the grassroots.
Cross-sector collaboration between the government, the Peatland and Mangrove Restoration Agency (BRGM), academics, grassroots social movements and civil-society alliances is a key catalyst for pressing for regulatory improvements and climate justice.
Indonesia’s climate and land crisis is not merely a technical problem of extinguishing fire hotspots; it is a political and economic crisis that requires the moral courage to overhaul the existing order. We cannot save the Earth and protect the integrity of peatland ecosystems without changing the extractive economic system that is destroying them.
Amid today’s global challenges, humanity and the Indonesian nation face an urgent existential choice: to continue defending an outdated system that brings ecological destruction, or to dare to forge radical collaboration for a just, resilient and sustainable future.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/climate-justice-and-forest-and-land-fires-in-indonesia-1793713926)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/791158/keadilan-iklim-dan-karhutla-di-indonesia), translated from Indonesian