Claims Rejected, Customers Sue: Who Is Really at Fault?
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — Over the past three years, lawsuits over insurance disputes at the South Jakarta District Court have risen significantly. The increase highlights that the insurance industry’s challenge is not only preventing fraud, but also ensuring that claim refusals are transparent, proportionate and consistent with the contract.
At the same time, the industry faces the threat of organised claims fraud involving collusion among rogue employees, agents and members of the public who deliberately buy policies to obtain illicit gains.
The principle of utmost good faith must apply in both directions: customers must honestly disclose risks, while insurers must be open, diligent and fair in honouring their promise of protection.
Insurance is bought to provide financial certainty when risks materialise. Customers pay premiums regularly in the expectation that insurers will meet their obligations when misfortune strikes. However, this relationship does not always run smoothly. In some cases, claims end in rejection, disputes and even court proceedings.
One recurring problem is disagreement over whether a claim is valid. Insurers may refuse payment after finding information they believe was not disclosed when the policy was issued, a suspected pre-existing medical condition, inconsistencies in the policy application or indications that the claim does not meet the policy terms.
Customers, on the other hand, may feel they have met their premium-payment and claims requirements and question why information challenged only when a claim is made was not adequately clarified when the policy was issued. Many also feel that the reasons for rejection are not explained transparently.
The issue is further complicated because insurers face not only the risk of claims that do not meet policy terms, but also the potential for organised claims fraud. In some schemes, perpetrators do not act alone. People with access to sales, policy issuance, data management or claims assessment may be involved.
The insurance industry therefore faces two challenges at once: protecting customers entitled to benefits and preventing payments obtained through manipulation or fraud.
Court lawsuits
A preliminary review of cases at the South Jakarta District Court from 2024 to 2026 identified at least 31 lawsuits involving insurance companies: six in 2024, seven in 2025 and 18 in 2026.
These figures are based on an initial identification and do not represent the total number of insurance cases registered with the court. Not all the cases listed concern rejected claims, nor are they all related to suspected fraud. Some involve breach-of-contract disputes, others claims of unlawful acts, as well as corporate insurance disputes.
Nevertheless, this initial overview shows that contractual relationships between customers and insurers can give rise to a range of disputes. The cases also indicate that disputes concern not only life and health insurance for individuals, but corporate cover as well.
One case attracting attention is lawsuit No. 1097/Pdt.G/2025/PN JKT.SEL. PT Tambang Tondano Nusajaya and PT Archi Indonesia Tbk sued 18 general insurance companies over an alleged breach of contract. In its 2025 annual report, Archi Indonesia said its subsidiary was involved in a civil case concerning an unpaid insurance claim. The case is now at the appeal stage after the trial court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs approximately Rp1.3 trillion in damages, plus annual interest of 6%.
In the life and health insurance segment, several cases show how disagreements over health information can develop into lawsuits. One example is case No. 1314/Pdt.G/2026/PN JKT.SEL, involving Riati Hulu and PT Great Eastern Life Indonesia. The lawsuit was filed on 22 October 2026, with Rp1.005 billion at stake, and is listed as being at its first hearing.
In an official response to CNBC Indonesia, Great Eastern Life’s management said the company respected the ongoing legal process and would follow each stage in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.
“PT Great Eastern Life Indonesia remains committed to providing professional service to all customers, including in the handling of claims in accordance with the applicable policy terms, while upholding the principles of good corporate governance, business ethics and compliance with regulatory requirements,” management wrote.
The rise in lawsuits against insurers underscores that claim disputes can arise from a range of issues, including differing interpretations of policy clauses, disclosure of medical histories, claim-submission administration and alleged breaches of contractual obligations.
The number of lawsuits should not, therefore, be taken as proof that insurers systematically reject claims unlawfully; that must still be established in court. Nonetheless, the cases are a signal that the industry should review the quality of its sales, policy-issuance and claims-handling processes.
Organised claims fraud
Behind disputes between insurers and customers in court lies another serious threat: manipulating claims to obtain payments to which the perpetrators are not entitled.
In some schemes, claims fraud is not the work of one person forging documents alone. It may involve a network of prospective policyholders, sales agents, rogue company employees and external parties with access to information or supporting documents.
This pattern is known as organised insurance fraud. Perpetrators exploit gaps in sales, risk selection (underwriting), policy issuance, administration or claims assessment to create insurance transactions intended from the outset to generate illicit gains.
One pattern to watch for is the purchase of a policy with the intention of manipulating it when a claim is made. In such cases, insurance is no longer bought to transfer a risk that may arise in the future, but to use the policy as a means of obtaining money through fabricated events or information.
In this scenario, an agent may recruit prospective policyholders, help with applications or direct them to provide information that does not reflect the truth. If rogue insiders are involved, risk assessment or document verification may also be abused.
A director at a life insurance company said suspected claims fraud could be indicated by repeated claim lawsuits originating in the same area. There were even suspicions that some lawyers were involved in mobilising customers to file claims. As a result, the insurer marked the area as a “red zone” and would reject all policy applications originating there.
Examples of claims fraud
In the United States, the FBI uncovered a network in 2019 that had staged at least 33 vehicle accidents over six years to obtain insurance payments totalling US$5.6 million. In 2023, a restaurant owner set fire to his own business to file a fraudulent insurance claim worth US$305,400. The perpetrator, James Purifoy, was caught and sentenced to five years in prison in May 2026.
In Malaysia, police uncovered a syndicate that used fake agents to issue policies in other people’s names without the insured parties’ knowledge. After the policies were issued, the victims were allegedly murdered and their deaths staged as accidents to obtain payouts. One policy uncovered was worth RM500,000, equivalent to Rp2.2 billion.
In Hong Kong, police uncovered nine people suspected of filing around 70 fictitious travel claims worth HK$1.7 million, or approximately Rp3.91 billion. The documents used included fake tickets, hotel receipts and medical records. Several suspects were believed to have worked as insurance agents.
In China, a student filed fictitious claims with five insurance companies worth NT$41.26 million, equivalent to Rp22.7 billion, after allegedly staging the circumstances in which his legs were amputated following frostbite. Four insurers rejected the claims after detecting inconsistencies.
In Indonesia, in 2022, a Bekasi resident named Wahyu Suhada tried to stage his own death by pretending to fall into the Kalimalang River. His aim was to obtain approximately Rp15 billion in insurance benefits. In 2025, a suspected murder case involving an insurance claim was reported in Deli Serdang. A teenager was initially believed to have been the victim of a hit-and-run, but further investigation by the criminal investigation unit found a connection to an insurance claim handled by the victim’s aunt.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/claims-rejected-customers-sue-who-is-really-at-fault-1794383487)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20261111121315-128-784223/klaim-ditolak-nasabah-menggugat-siapa-sebenarnya-yang-salah), translated from Indonesian