Civil Society Key to Driving State Compliance with ICJ Climate Advisory Opinion
The active role of civil society is considered a determining factor in encouraging countries to comply with the International Court of Justice (ICJ) Advisory Opinion on climate change. In a discussion initiated by the Indonesian Forum for the Environment (WALHI), University of Brawijaya academic Prischa Listiningrum explained how the power of public movements can open up diplomatic space and new international mechanisms to realise climate justice.
Prischa noted that the birth of the 2023 United Nations (UN) General Assembly Resolution requesting a legal opinion from the ICJ was the fruit of civil society struggle. The movement was initiated by a group of law students in the Pacific Islands who are members of Pacific Island Students Fighting Climate Change. Their struggle influenced the Government of Vanuatu to successfully bring the idea to the UN General Assembly until it was unanimously supported by all member states without objection.
“So this resolution was born from the struggle of civil society, namely a group of law students in the Pacific Islands, in Vanuatu, the organisation is called Pacific Island Students Fighting Climate Change,” said Prischa on Tuesday (7/7/2026).
This initial success demonstrates that civil society has a significant capacity to direct the international legal agenda. Following the issuance of the Advisory Opinion by the ICJ, the role of civil society becomes even more crucial in overseeing the establishment of a compliance mechanism at the UN General Assembly.
Unlike the ICJ, which produces legal products, the UN resolution is a diplomatic and political product aimed at following up on the advisory opinion. Civil society is encouraged to prepare for the 82nd Session of the UN General Assembly in the 2027–2028 period, when the UN typically opens space for public participation to provide input regarding the operationalisation of the climate resolution.
The opportunity to utilise new legal foundations is now wide open for civil society organisations (CSOs). Considering the ICJ affirmed that the climate crisis intersects with various other international legal regimes, civil society is no longer confined to formal climate change forums such as the Conference of the Parties (COP). The legal basis from the ICJ Advisory Opinion can be brought to various other international mechanisms, including the Convention on Biological Diversity forum, the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), and human rights compliance reviews.
“For example, if colleagues want to submit a report in the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) process regarding human rights compliance in Indonesia, they can very much bring the climate crisis issue there,” explained Prischa.
This provides more legal grounds for civil society to file strategic lawsuits and demands against state policies that damage the environment. At the domestic level, Prischa highlighted the importance of civil society criticising the energy transition so that it does not burden the poor, as well as overseeing strict regulations on business actors as the largest emitters.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/civil-society-key-to-driving-state-compliance-with-icj-climate-advisory-opinion-1783428768)
Originally published by Republika (https://esgnow.republika.co.id/berita/tht0fk423/masyarakat-sipil-jadi-kunci-mendorong-kepatuhan-negara-terhadap-fatwa-iklim-icj), translated from Indonesian