Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Civil Society Coalition Condemns TNI Commander's Statement on Public Security Responsibility

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Security Sector Reform
Civil Society Coalition Condemns TNI Commander's Statement on Public Security Responsibility
Image: detikcom

The Civil Society Coalition for Security Sector Reform has condemned a statement by TNI Commander General Agus Subiyanto in which he claimed responsibility for public security across Indonesia. The statement was made alongside an explanation that the TNI has been and will continue to conduct patrols in various regions, including to anticipate possible demonstrations such as those that took place in August last year.

“The statement cannot be regarded as merely a poor choice of words. The claim of being responsible for public security shows that the boundary between defence and domestic security functions is increasingly being blurred. Furthermore, the statement risks legitimising the presence of the military as something normal in civilian life,” the Civil Society Coalition said in a written statement to journalists on Tuesday (11/8/2026).

The Civil Society Coalition referred to the constitution, which regulates the duties and roles of the TNI and the National Police. Article 30 of the 1945 Constitution places the TNI as a state instrument tasked with defending, protecting, and maintaining the integrity and sovereignty of the state, while public security and order, protection of and services to citizens, and law enforcement are the responsibility of the National Police.

“This division is not merely an administrative matter. The separation of the TNI and the National Police is one of the important achievements of Reformasi to end the dual function of ABRI and military dominance in civilian affairs, as affirmed in MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2000 and MPR Decree No. VII/MPR/2000. Indonesia has a long and bitter experience when the military was given too much space in public life: freedoms were silenced, violence was tolerated, human rights violations occurred, while accountability was difficult to obtain,” the coalition said.

According to the Civil Society Coalition, past experience shows the risks when the military gains too much space in public life. They said such conditions once contributed to the silencing of freedoms, violence, human rights violations, and weak accountability.

“Therefore, the pretext of ‘coordination’, ‘collaboration’, or implementation based on SOPs is not sufficient to justify the deployment of the military in civilian spaces. SOPs are internal rules. They cannot create authority that is not granted by the constitution and laws,” the coalition explained.

“The most worrying aspect is when TNI patrols and deployment are linked to the possibility of demonstrations. Protests are not a threat to the state. They are a constitutional right of citizens to assemble, express opinions, and oversee the exercise of power,” the statement continued.

The coalition considers confronting demonstrations with military patrols to be a misguided approach. Such an approach has the potential to create fear and intimidation, especially for students, workers, farmers, indigenous communities, women, journalists, environmental defenders, human rights defenders, and other groups fighting for their rights.

“TNI involvement also carries serious risks. Soldiers may be drawn into conducting checks, arrests, interrogations, surveillance, or other law enforcement actions that are not within their authority. If violence occurs, the public will once again face a closed military accountability system that still leaves problems of impunity,” the coalition said.

The coalition stressed that criticism of TNI involvement does not mean condoning police violence and repressiveness. They questioned the government for deploying security forces to respond to criticism.

“The issue is not whether the public should be controlled by the TNI or the National Police. The question that must be answered is why the government continues to treat criticism, demonstrations, and public dissatisfaction as security disturbances that must be met with the deployment of security forces,” the coalition said.

Furthermore, Agus’s statement was seen as a setback for civilian supremacy. The coalition said many development programmes and civilian affairs have already been taken over by the military.

“The TNI Commander’s statement also does not stand alone. It emerges amid the increasingly broad involvement of the military in government, development programmes, and various affairs that should be handled by civilian institutions. This direction marks a regression of civilian supremacy and opens the way for the return of the military as a force that regulates public life,” the coalition explained.

“In a democratic state, the use of military force in civilian spaces must be an exception, not a habit. Every involvement must have a legal basis and reasons that can be tested, be limited by clear time and objectives, be subject to civilian control, and be open to public oversight,” the coalition added.

On that basis, the Civil Society Coalition for Security Sector Reform urged:

  1. The TNI Commander to retract and correct his statement and to stop claiming that the TNI is the main party responsible for public security across Indonesia.

  2. The President to immediately halt any military involvement in civilian security that lacks a legal basis, measurable need, time limit, and accountability mechanism.

  3. The National Police to clarify whether it has ever requested TNI assistance and the scope of such requests, while ensuring that TNI soldiers do not conduct checks, arrests, seizures, interrogations, surveillance of activists, or other law enforcement actions.

  4. The DPR to immediately summon the President, the TNI Commander, and the National Police Chief to demand an explanation and to ensure that the military does not take over civilian security functions.

  5. The TNI and the National Police to respect the public’s right to express opinions, to stop intimidation and security approaches to demonstrations, and to guarantee that no deployment of force hinders civil liberties.

Reformasi separated the military from civilian life so that violence, silencing, and impunity would not recur. That boundary must be maintained. The TNI is not the police, demonstrations are not a threat to the state, and Indonesia is not a military barracks.

More from 11 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/civil-society-coalition-condemns-tni-commanders-statement-on-public-security-responsibility-1786456387)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8614282/koalisi-sipil-kritik-pernyataan-panglima-tni-tanggung-jawab-keamanan-indonesia), translated from Indonesian
Print