Civil Coalition Calls Appeal Verdict in Andrie Yunus Case a Dangerous Message
A number of civil society organisations united in the Civil Society Coalition for Security Sector Reform have condemned the appeal verdict of the Military High Court in the acid attack case against KontraS Deputy External Coordinator Andrie Yunus, delivered on Friday (4/9).
The coalition considers the verdict, which reduced prison sentences and exempted two of the four defendants from dismissal sanctions, to be a failure of military justice.
According to the coalition, the verdict implicitly sends a signal to civil society that the military enjoys impunity under the law.
“The public receives a dangerous message: soldier status can serve as a shield from firm legal and service consequences,” the coalition said in a written statement on Saturday (5/9).
The coalition again criticised the military justice system in cases of ordinary criminal offences against civilians.
According to them, institutional conflicts of interest are difficult to avoid when investigators, prosecutors, judges, defendants, and case administration all operate within the same institutional environment.
“In cases that touch upon institutional interests, the chain of command, and soldiers’ careers, independence cannot merely be claimed. Independence must be visible, testable, and genuinely trusted by victims and the public,” the coalition’s statement read.
Yet the 1998 reform had provided clear direction that soldiers should be tried in military courts only for military criminal offences. For ordinary criminal offences, members should be examined in civilian courts.
The coalition believes that allowing guilty soldiers to remain in service weakens internal screening mechanisms, blurs the institution’s tolerance threshold for violence, and undermines guarantees of non-recurrence.
As a result, victims and witnesses become increasingly unsafe, human rights defenders face more tangible threats, and other soldiers may conclude that serious violence does not always lead to the loss of position and authority.
The coalition therefore rejects the appeal ruling in the case because it is not commensurate with the impact of the attack on the victim’s suffering, nor with the urgent need for deterrence and guarantees of non-recurrence.
Urging the Judicial Commission, Supreme Court and DPR
The coalition is urging the Supreme Court (MA) and the Judicial Commission (KY) to intervene and immediately examine the process and quality of the appeal considerations.
On the other hand, they are also urging the House of Representatives (DPR) to immediately revise Law Number 31/1997 on Military Justice. According to the coalition, military court jurisdiction must be limited to military criminal offences, not offences against civilians.
“Every ordinary criminal offence committed by TNI members—especially those whose victims are civilians—must be examined by civilian courts,” it said.
Those joining the coalition include Imparsial, KontraS, YLBHI, Amnesty International Indonesia, HRWG, WALHI, Centra Initiative, Raksha Initiatives, IRC, ICW, LBH Jakarta, SETARA Institute, LBH Pers, DeJure, LBH Masyarakat, ALDP, Public Virtue, ICJR, ELSAM, PBHI, AJI Jakarta, LBH APIK, KPI, LBH Medan, and AJI Indonesia.
Meanwhile, TNI Information Centre Head Major General Muhammad Nas asserted that his institution did not interfere with the court’s decision. He said TNI Headquarters respects the independence and authority of judges in deciding a case.
“Regarding the Military High Court ruling in question, it falls within the domain of military justice, which institutionally sits under the Supreme Court,” Nas said when contacted via written message on Friday evening.
The Jakarta Military High Court II removed dismissal sanctions and reduced prison sentences for two defendants in the acid attack on Andrie Yunus.
Based on the appeal verdict for case number 56-K/PMT-II/BDG/AL/VI/2026, Defendant I Second Sergeant Edi Sudarko was sentenced to 2 years and 6 months in prison.
Defendant II First Lieutenant Budhi Hariyanto Widhi was sentenced to 2 years in prison.
Defendant III Captain Nandala Dwi Prasetyo was meanwhile sentenced to 2 years in prison, and Defendant IV First Lieutenant Sami Lakka was sentenced to 1 year and 6 months in prison.
The appeal ruling amended the Jakarta Military Court II-08 decision Number 70-K/PM II-08/AL/IV/2026 dated 10 June 2026.
Based on the first-instance court ruling, Defendant I was sentenced to 3 years in prison and Defendant II was sentenced to 2 years and 6 months in prison. In addition to the prison sentences, the judge also imposed an additional penalty on both of them in the form of dismissal from military service.
Meanwhile, Defendant III was sentenced to 2 years in prison, and Defendant IV was sentenced to 1 year and 6 months in prison.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/civil-coalition-calls-appeal-verdict-in-andrie-yunus-case-a-dangerous-message-1788699083)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260906184145-12-1400715/koalisi-sipil-soal-vonis-banding-kasus-andrie-yunus-pesan-berbahaya), translated from Indonesian