Citizen Challenges Railway Law at Constitutional Court, Demands Free Tickets for Children Under Five
A citizen named Jangkung Sido Sentosa has officially filed a judicial review petition against Law Number 23 of 2007 concerning Railways with the Constitutional Court (MK). The lawsuit focuses on the interpretation of special facility rights for children, specifically regarding train ticket tariff policies.
The petition has been registered with the Constitutional Court under Case Number 288/PUU-XXIV/2026. In the filing, the petitioner questions the constitutionality of Article 131 paragraph (1) of the Railway Law, which is deemed not to provide maximum protection for toddlers.
The contested article states: ‘Railway facility operators shall provide special facilities and conveniences for persons with disabilities, pregnant women, children under five years of age, sick persons, and the elderly.’
The petitioner argues that the phrase ‘special facilities’ in the article should include a full exemption from ticket fees for children aged 0 to 5 years. However, in practice, the petitioner observes a discrepancy between the legal text and its implementation by railway operators.
In the petition submitted on Tuesday (28/7), Jangkung highlighted a potential constitutional loss caused by PT Kereta Api Indonesia’s (KAI) policy. Currently, PT KAI only provides free tickets to infants aged 0 to 3 years. ‘This restriction forces the petitioner to pay full fare for a child aged 3 years, even though the law guarantees this right up to the age of 5,’ the petitioner stated in the court documents.
According to the petitioner, the age limit for free tickets represents a unilateral interpretation by the operator that harms citizens’ rights, given that the law explicitly mentions the category of ‘children under five years of age’.
Jangkung argued that providing a zero fare for children aged 0-5 years is not merely an economic policy, but a form of affirmative action to protect vulnerable groups. Physically and legally, toddlers are considered dependent and thus entitled to special treatment from the state through public service providers.
The petitioner referred to Article 28H paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution, which mandates that every person has the right to facilities and special treatment to obtain equal opportunities and benefits in the pursuit of equality and justice. Therefore, the fulfilment of this right should not depend on the economic capacity of the child’s parents.
To strengthen the arguments before the panel of constitutional justices, the petitioner included comparative practices of railway services in other countries. Through this petition, Jangkung Sido Sentosa requests that the Constitutional Court declare the phrase ‘children under five years of age’ in Article 131 paragraph (1) of the Railway Law to be constitutionally conditional, meaning it must be interpreted as including the provision of free tickets. Should the panel of justices hold a different opinion, the petitioner requests that the case be decided based on the principle of justice (ex aequo et bono).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/citizen-challenges-railway-law-at-constitutional-court-demands-free-tickets-for-children-under-five-1785228649)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/915525/uji-materi-uu-perkeretaapian-pemohon-minta-tiket-kereta-gratis-anak-usia-0-5-tahun), translated from Indonesian