Circumcision in Children Using a Clamp: Four Benefits and Four Risks to Know
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Circumcision is a common medical procedure for boys. As healthcare technology develops, a wider range of methods has become available, including clamp circumcision, which is often offered as an alternative to conventional circumcision.
The clamp method uses a special device to hold the foreskin—the skin covering the head of the penis—in place before it is cut. It is claimed to offer several benefits, including a relatively short procedure and a lower risk of bleeding.
However, the method is not entirely risk-free. Parents should understand its advantages and disadvantages before choosing a circumcision method for their child.
Several types of clamps are used in medical procedures, including the Gomco and Mogen clamps. Plastic devices such as the Plastibell are also used for circumcision.
Although these devices work on similar principles, each has different mechanisms, benefits and risks. Their use should also be tailored to the child’s age and anatomy.
Benefits
1. The procedure is relatively quick
One advantage of the clamp method is that the procedure takes relatively little time. The specialised device enables the doctor to remove the foreskin through a more straightforward process.
A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis published in Current Urology Reports found that plastic clamp techniques had an average operating time around 17 minutes shorter than conventional surgery.
2. It can help reduce bleeding
The clamp applies pressure to the foreskin tissue, compressing blood vessels during the cutting process.
This mechanism helps control bleeding. The same study also found that plastic clamp techniques resulted in less blood loss than conventional surgery.
3. Stitches are not always needed
Some clamp devices are designed to allow the circumcision wound to be managed without additional stitches, which can make the procedure more straightforward.
Whether stitches are needed still depends on the type of device, the child’s age and tissue condition, and the doctor’s assessment.
4. The procedure is relatively practical
The specialised device helps the doctor cut the foreskin in a controlled way. With certain devices, the clamping mechanism also helps protect the tissue around the head of the penis.
Risks
1. Risk of swelling after circumcision
Although the clamp method can help reduce bleeding, it does not necessarily mean recovery will be faster.
The 2024 meta-analysis found that plastic clamp techniques carried a higher risk of post-operative swelling than conventional surgery.
2. It is not suitable for every child
Not every child can undergo clamp circumcision. Factors such as penile abnormalities, unsuitable anatomical dimensions or certain health conditions may lead doctors to consider another technique.
A medical examination before the procedure is therefore essential.
3. Injury if the device is fitted incorrectly
Incorrect placement can injure penile tissue, including the head of the penis. The risk may be higher if the procedure is performed by a healthcare professional without adequate skills.
4. Aftercare is still required
Although the procedure is relatively straightforward, the child still needs wound care after circumcision. Parents should keep the genital area clean, follow instructions on medication and arrange check-ups as recommended by the doctor.
Is clamp circumcision painless?
The clamp method does not eliminate pain entirely. An anaesthetic is still needed to reduce pain during the procedure.
Once the anaesthetic wears off, the child may continue to feel pain, sensitivity or discomfort in the penile area during recovery.
Parents should therefore not choose a method based solely on speed or reduced bleeding. They should ensure that the procedure is performed by a competent doctor or healthcare professional, with an appropriate device and adequate medical facilities.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/circumcision-in-children-using-a-clamp-four-benefits-and-four-risks-to-know-1794714758)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5855091/sunat-klamp-pada-anak-4-keunggulan-dan-4-risiko-yang-perlu-diketahui), translated from Indonesian