China Succeeds as the World's Factory, Yet Its People Remain Unconfident
China has now become one of the world’s greatest industrial powers. Chinese manufactured products are not only superior in terms of low costs but are also beginning to dominate more sophisticated, high-value sectors.
According to The Economist, Chinese manufacturers have become serious competitors in various industries previously dominated by advanced nations. China has successfully overtaken German car manufacturers, moved faster than South Korean shipbuilders, and is closing the gap with United States chip designers.
This success has caused concern among many nations. Several world leaders are now attempting to limit dependency on China, particularly in strategic industries.
The European Union, for instance, will hold a meeting in late June to discuss firmer measures. One option being considered is requiring European companies to diversify their suppliers to avoid over-reliance on components from China.
Strong Exports, But Weak Consumers
For the Chinese government, the surge in exports is a source of pride. Chinese exports grew by more as than 19% year-on-year in May. This trade performance has helped the Chinese economy survive following the bursting of the property bubble in 2021.
China’s dominance in the global supply chain also grants the nation significant geopolitical influence amidst an increasingly competitive world.
Chinese leaders believe that a nation’s strength depends heavily on technological progress and manufacturing capability. While strength in the Mao Zedong era was linked to heavy industry and the military, his successors now hope that high-tech exports will make China increasingly indispensable to the world.
However, this progress in high-tech industry has not been fully felt by the Chinese populace. Consumer confidence has not recovered since the Covid-19 lockdowns and the pressures within the property sector. Even the stock market rally in late 2024 was insufficient to lift public optimism.
In April, China’s retail sales rose by only 0.2% compared to the same period the previous year, even before adjustments for inflation. Car sales also plummeted by more than a fifth. This suggests that looking at overall economic health, rather than just industrial strength, China’s growth model is beginning to show weaknesses.
There are several reasons why China’s industrial dominance does not automatically lead to a strong economic recovery.
Firstly, China’s current export success does not create as many jobs as in the past. Previously, the export boom attracted millions of migrant workers to factories in coastal regions. Now, China’s leading industries no longer absorb much labour due to increasing technological intensity.
Export prices are also rising faster than export volumes. Meanwhile, spending on electric vehicles generates fewer jobs per yuan compared to the same amount spent on conventional cars or new housing construction.
The proportion of migrant workers in the manufacturing sector has dropped from nearly 37% in 2010 to 28% last year. Many of them are now working as food delivery couriers or in other sectors of the gig economy. In other words, they are more often on bicycle paths rather than factory assembly lines.
Advanced Industry is Not Enough to Support the Economy
Another issue is that China’s high-tech industry is highly concentrated in only a few cities. This concentration is a strength, as it allows suppliers to specialise, human resources to cluster, and new ideas to spread more rapidly.
However, this condition also widens the gap between developed and lagging regions. China’s old growth model, which relied on property development, was spread across almost the entire country, including less promising areas. In contrast, the new model based on high-tech industry is far more selective regarding location.
As a result, the share of inland provinces in China’s industry fell from nearly 48% in 2013 to just 36% last year.
The massive push into high-tech industry also poses fiscal problems. Ideally, new industries should expand the tax base and increase local government revenue. In China, however, the flow of funds often moves in the opposite direction.
Municipal and provincial governments are competing to support local companies in future-oriented sectors through tax incentives and subsidies. This move is actually weakening their financial positions. Fiscal support has also led to too many companies entering popular industries, thereby squeezing the profits of actually efficient firms.
Last year, consultants AlixPartners estimated that only 15 out of 129 Chinese electric vehicle brands will be financially viable by 2030.
At first glance, China’s export success should help offset its weak domestic economy. However, the opposite is happening. Weak domestic consumer spending has driven down prices, low interest rates, and a cheap currency. All these factors make Chinese products increasingly competitive in the global market.
At the same time, strong exports are propping up economic growth. This allows Chinese policymakers to delay more difficult measures to restore consumer confidence, such as increasing social spending or re-stabilising the property market.
While European leaders are attempting to reduce supply dependency on China, Chinese leaders should be doing something similar domestically. The difference is that China needs to diversify not only its sources of supply but also its sources of economic demand, so as not to rely too heavily on exports and manufacturing.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/china-succeeds-as-the-worlds-factory-yet-its-people-remain-unconfident-1781347875)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20260612113056-128-742285/china-sukses-jadi-pabrik-dunia-tapi-rakyatnya-belum-percaya-diri), translated from Indonesian