China on Edge as Its Citizens Become Increasingly Reluctant to Borrow from Banks
China’s economy is showing fresh signs of concern. As the government seeks to encourage people to spend more, citizens are becoming increasingly cautious about parting with their money.
People in China are not only cutting back on spending but are also taking out fewer bank loans. This presents a new challenge for a government that has spent several years trying to revive consumer demand.
A report by The Economist said short-term consumer loans in China fell 8.3% year on year in September 2026, the sharpest decline on record. The previous month, outstanding consumer loans had already fallen to their lowest level since China imposed strict Covid-19 restrictions.
Chinese consumers also appeared more frugal during the early October 2026 holiday period. Average spending over the holiday fell 2% compared with the same period a year earlier.
This is unwelcome news for both Chinese businesses and the government. Since the end of the pandemic, Beijing has been trying to persuade people to spend more, but consumers are increasingly reluctant to borrow and banks are finding it harder to extend credit.
Why are people in China borrowing less?
One reason is the country’s ongoing property crisis. For years, buying a home was one of the main reasons Chinese households took out large loans. But as the property market has weakened and home sales have continued to fall, fewer people are applying for mortgages.
Some people who still have home loans are even choosing to repay them early when they have extra money. As a result, household debt in China is no longer growing as it once did.
In 2020, household debt amounted to about 60% of China’s gross domestic product (GDP). The ratio then remained broadly unchanged for several years before edging down slightly in 2025. By comparison, household debt in advanced economies is just under 70% of GDP.
But the property crisis is not the only reason borrowing is declining. Banks are also becoming increasingly concerned about the growing number of people struggling to repay their debts.
Banks are becoming wary of lending
The Chinese government has sought to make borrowing more affordable. In 2025, it began providing subsidies to banks so they could offer lower interest rates on loans for major purchases, such as new cars or home renovations.
The intention was that cheaper loans would encourage people to borrow and spend again. But the results have fallen short of expectations.
Banks are becoming more cautious about lending as more borrowers run into repayment difficulties. According to calculations by consultancy Gavekal cited by The Economist, more than 10% of China’s adult population was estimated to have unpaid debt in 2025, up from less than 8% in 2024.
The increase has made banks more concerned that they will not recover the money they lend. When the risk of default rises, banks would normally charge higher interest rates to offset potential losses. Yet the Chinese government is trying to lower borrowing costs through subsidies, leaving banks in a difficult position.
They are being encouraged to lend at low rates even as the risk of borrowers failing to repay increases. To avoid losses, banks are becoming more selective, making it harder for people considered at greater risk of default to obtain credit.
China’s bad loans are now selling at steep discounts
The difficulties facing Chinese banks do not end there. When customers fail to repay their loans, banks are also finding it harder to sell the debts to other parties.
Banks can usually sell bad loans to companies or investors specialising in distressed debt. Buyers acquire the claims at a discount and then try to collect the money from borrowers.
For example, if someone owes 100 yuan but has long stopped making repayments, a bank may sell the claim to an investor at a lower price rather than continue waiting for uncertain payment.
At the start of 2021, a bad loan with a face value of 100 yuan could typically be sold for about 30 yuan, or 30% of its value. By early 2026, the price had plunged to just 5 yuan, or 5% of the debt’s face value.
The fall suggests investors are increasingly worried they will be unable to recover money from borrowers in arrears. For banks, this is a significant problem: when customers cannot repay, it is becoming harder to sell their claims without taking a substantial loss.
China bans abusive debt-collection tactics
The decline may be linked to new government rules intended to protect the public. For years, debt collection in China was known for being highly aggressive. Some collection companies used a range of tactics to pressure people into repaying their loans.
These included making repeated calls throughout the day, contacting borrowers’ family and friends, and visiting their homes in the middle of the night. Some collectors reportedly called borrowers and people close to them hundreds of times a day.
Other tactics included disclosing a person’s debts to their family, friends or employer to shame them. In more extreme cases, collectors created obscene images to humiliate borrowers and circulated them among people they knew.
Such practices are known in China as “soft violence”, or violence without physical contact. The pressure has sometimes had grave consequences: The Economist has documented cases of people taking their own lives after facing debt-related intimidation.
The government had previously tried to stamp out such practices through legal action. In 2026, however, it introduced stricter nationwide rules on debt collection.
Since August 2026, collectors have been allowed to call borrowers no more than six times a day and have been barred from contacting their family and friends. They are also prohibited from visiting borrowers’ homes in the middle of the night, and all communications between collectors and borrowers must be recorded.
The rules are welcome news for people who have faced pressure from debt collectors. But they have also raised new concerns for the banking industry.
Some analysts suspect that tighter collection rules have contributed to the fall in the prices of bad loans. Without intimidation tactics, collection companies must find other ways to secure payment from borrowers in arrears. For companies buying banks’ bad debts, this makes the prospect of recovering their money more uncertain, reducing their willingness to pay higher prices.
Analysts believe this may be one reason bad loans have fallen in value so sharply, from around 30% of their face value in early 2021 to just 5% in early 2026. However, the connection between the new rules and the price collapse remains a hypothesis.
China is now facing a complicated problem. The government wants people to spend more to accelerate the economy, but consumers are becoming more cautious about taking on debt. Banks, meanwhile, are increasingly reluctant to lend as the risk of default rises.
At the same time, rules designed to protect people from excessive debt-collection pressure may also be making it harder for banks to deal with bad loans. This is a fresh challenge for China as it seeks to make consumer spending a key driver of economic growth.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/china-on-edge-as-its-citizens-become-increasingly-reluctant-to-borrow-from-banks-1792162282)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20261015130727-128-776464/china-ketar-ketir-warganya-makin-ogah-pinjam-uang-ke-bank), translated from Indonesian