Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Challenging the Opiate of Submission: When Faith is Divorced from Reason

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Challenging the Opiate of Submission: When Faith is Divorced from Reason
Image: Media Indonesia

Anxious rulers always have ways to lull the public’s consciousness. One of the oldest, most subtle, and deadliest strategies is fostering religiosity without reason. On this stage, the people are permitted, even facilitated, to pray all day long, provided they never ask why their lives remain miserable. They are encouraged to look up to the heavens precisely so they forget to observe the tangible inequality on earth.

In the contemporary Indonesian context, this symptom is increasingly visible. We often witness how ritual piety is celebrated on a colossal scale, while at the same time, critical reasoning is extinguished. Prayers of submission are praised, while criticism of policy is suspected as an act of ingratitude or even subversion. It is as if structural poverty, rampant corruption, and a legal system that is sharp downwards are divine destinies to be accepted with patience, rather than socio-political problems that must be solved.

The manipulation of piety to perpetuate power is nothing new. World history is a vast laboratory demonstrating how religion, when reduced to a tool of domestication, gives birth to absolute oppression. In medieval Europe before the Renaissance, the church institution and European monarchs formed a tight alliance. The doctrine of the Divine Right of Kings was used to justify that the king was God’s representative on earth who could not be challenged. The people were forced to accept suffering in this world for the sake of happiness in the afterlife, while church dogma tightly shut the doors to science and philosophy. Anyone who used their critical reason, like Galileo Galilei, was branded a heretic. In the hands of the rulers of that era, religion successfully became an opiate that paralysed the critical power of the masses.

In another part of the world, history records the tactical alliance between Muhammad bin Saud and Muhammad bin Abdul Wahhab in the 18th century. Wahhabism provided absolute religious legitimacy to the Saud ruler, with its main doctrine: blind obedience to the waliyyul amri (leader) and a strict prohibition on criticising the ruler in public. In return, the ruler supported this puritanical preaching. The result? The absolute power of the Saud dynasty was preserved for centuries atop a narrative of ritual obedience, while the political spaces of citizens were tightly sealed.

In Indonesia, the pattern shifts cosmetically, but the substance is similar. We see symptoms of the commodification of piety, where political elites suddenly become religious ahead of elections, donning religious symbols and donating to houses of worship. Yet, the policies they produce often marginalise the poor, destroy living spaces through reckless investment, and widen the gap of inequality. The ruler prefers a populace that is devout in submission over a populace that thinks. Because a free mind cannot be directed by normative speeches, social assistance, or the threat of elastic legal articles.

A free mind will pose questions that make the seat of power tremble. Who actually enjoys the fruits of this development? Why is the law blunt upwards? Why does power always demand the people’s understanding but is allergic to oversight? This is the ruler’s greatest fear. Their fear is not of crowded mosques, churches, temples, or viharas. Their fear is of the awareness beginning to grow in the people’s heads. As long as houses of worship only produce personal prayers without social sensitivity, power will sleep soundly.

Religion, in its essence, is not an enemy of freedom. The history of our nation’s movement records how progressive Islam, liberation theology in Catholicism and Christianity, and local spiritualities became the primary fuel for fighting colonialism. Religion can and must be a source of moral courage. Therefore, the task of the free people today—academics, activists, and conscious citizens—is not to distance the people from faith. Our urgent task is to reunite faith with reason. Religion fused with social awareness will never become a tool of oppression, but rather a force for liberation. We must restore religion to its prophetic function: defending the oppressed and fighting tyranny. When the Indonesian people begin to believe with sound reason, their prayers will no longer be mere lamentations or passive pleas, but a manifesto and a firm resolve to change the circumstances.

More from 17 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/challenging-the-opiate-of-submission-when-faith-is-divorced-from-reason-1781682688)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/opini/901373/menggugat-candu-ketundukan-ketika-iman-dipisahkan-dari-akal-sehat), translated from Indonesian
Print