Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Challenges in Developing the Sharia Economy in a Muslim-Majority Nation

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Challenges in Developing the Sharia Economy in a Muslim-Majority Nation
Image: Republika

Indonesia holds the distinction of being home to the world’s largest Muslim population, with 251.3 million people, or approximately 87 per cent of the total 288.3 million residents, projected for 2025. This massive figure is often used as a basis for optimism that the national Sharia economy will grow rapidly, under the assumption that market size must correlate directly with potential.

However, reality tells a different story; Indonesia’s Sharia banking market share remains around 7 per cent, far from the ambitious targets repeatedly set by the government over the last decade.

The author argues that the root of the problem lies not solely in product supply or regulation, but on the demand side. The majority of the Indonesian population is Muslim by administrative identity (KTP), but not necessarily in practice or substantive understanding. As long as this foundation remains fragile, Sharia economy campaigns relying on the narrative of the sin of usury (riba) will struggle to find resonance in a society where many disregard even the sin of neglecting the five daily prayers.

Mandatory Worship is Ignored, Let Alone the Prohibition of Riba

Data from the Indonesia Moslem Report released by the Alvara Research Centre—a national survey of 1,567 respondents across 34 provinces—found that only 38.9 per cent of Indonesian Muslims consistently perform the five daily prayers without fail. The remainder are spread across various levels of laxity, ranging from those who pray routinely but rarely in congregation, to those who frequently miss prayers, to those who only perform this obligation occasionally.

Prayer is the second pillar of Islam, the most fundamental obligation taught from an early age. If compliance with such a fundamental obligation is consistently maintained by only about three out of ten people, it is difficult to imagine the urgency of avoiding riba, a prohibition that is more transactional, more abstract, and only deeply understood by a small segment of society.

This gap is exacerbated by low basic religious literacy. A 2023 Ministry of Religious Affairs survey of 10,347 respondents found that only 44.57 per cent were able to read the Al-Qur’an correctly according to the rules of tajwid, and only 48.96 per cent could read fluently. When reading the holy book itself is a challenge for the majority, understanding the much more complex principles of fiqh muamalah—covering contracts (akad), usury (riba), uncertainty (gharar), and gambling (maisir)—becomes a compounded challenge.

More from 28 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/challenges-in-developing-the-sharia-economy-in-a-muslim-majority-nation-1790593179)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tm28d1502/tantangan-mengembangkan-ekonomi-syariah-di-negara-dengan-mayoritas-islam-ktp), translated from Indonesian
Print