Can Trump Pressure Israel to Accept the Gaza Peace Plan?
US President Donald Trump has called the new Gaza peace plan a “historic breakthrough.”
But so far, the peace plan announced last week to end the fighting and ease the humanitarian crisis has only led to a new deadlock for the warring parties.
Experts point to several differences between the new peace deal and previous agreements.
First, the agreement is far more detailed and substantive. Second, Trump’s statements suggest he may be willing to press Israel to accept the peace deal. Finally, after opposing the idea for years, this month the Gaza-based Hamas group agreed to disarm.
Hamas sent its fighters to step up attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023. More than 1,000 people were killed as a result, prompting Israel to launch a massive military operation in Gaza that has lasted nearly three years.
The Israeli military has killed more than 73,000 people in Gaza. A UN independent commission of inquiry has classified Israel’s military actions as genocide.
The crucial point in any Gaza peace plan is the sequence of events. Israel demands that Hamas disarm before Israel withdraws its troops from Gaza.
In early July, Hamas refused to disarm before Israel pulled out its forces. There was no common ground, resulting in a prolonged deadlock. However, Hamas has agreed to hand over power to the National Committee for Gaza Administration (NCAG), an independent technocratic group formed to govern Gaza.
At the end of July, Hamas also agreed to hand over its weapons to the NCAG.
Why is Hamas doing this?
Hamas’s decision to disarm after years of fighting against Israel should be taken seriously, said Muhammad Shehada, a visiting researcher from Gaza on the Middle East and North Africa programme at the European Council on Foreign Affairs.
Hamas is under pressure from the negotiating countries: Egypt and Qatar. This could be a political tactic “to show that Israel is the party blocking any progress in Gaza, under the government of (Prime Minister Benjamin) Netanyahu,” Shehada said.
But Shehada added, “They would not make such a major and historic concession unless they were truly cornered and understood that this is the only way.”
If Israel agrees to the new peace plan, Hamas would also be unable to renege on it.
“They will be bound,” Shehada told DW. “Because if they violate the disarmament agreement, they will give Israel an absolute reason to resume military operations in Gaza and derail the entire Trump deal. Hamas would then be blamed by the entire Palestinian public.”
On the other hand, Hamas may also understand that Israel is most likely not going to agree to the deal. So there is no need to worry that the disarmament process will happen soon, he added.
Israel immediately voiced objections to the new 15-point deal proposed by the US.
“The version that has been published does not reflect Israel’s position,” a spokesman for the Israeli prime minister’s office told the AFP news agency.
Israeli far-right minister Itamar Ben-Gvir said on social media that the deal was “unacceptable”, adding that “the killing in Gaza must continue.”
Israel will hold elections in October and Netanyahu faces stiff competition. If he makes any concessions on Gaza, he is likely to face public protests and a shortage of potential coalition partners from far-right parties.
“Netanyahu faces a crucial election in less than 90 days and while there may be some leeway on other issues such as Lebanon or Iran, he cannot appear flexible on Hamas,” explained Aaron David Miller, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
“The shadow of 7 October still hangs very dark and heavy over Israel, and will continue to do so for a long time,” the senior fellow said.
Netanyahu will try to derail any form of peace deal in Gaza until the Israeli election takes place, because it would be tantamount to “political suicide” for him, Shehada added.
After a meeting on Monday between Netanyahu and the US-led Peace Council, it was announced that Hamas’s disarmament and the withdrawal of Israeli forces would no longer be carried out in stages, as detailed in the new 15-point plan.
Observers say gradual progress is important to give each side time to build trust.
After Israel protested, the plan appeared to return to an absolute starting point: Israel would only withdraw after Hamas was completely disarmed.
According to Shehada and other experts, there is really only one way to change this: pressure from the US.
“Israel … will be under enormous pressure from Trump to follow the plan or risk provoking his anger by derailing what he claims is a historic breakthrough,” wrote Alan Pino, a senior fellow in the Atlantic Council’s Middle East programme, in an opinion piece for the US think tank last week.
There has already been some evidence of pressure from Trump. For example, when the US president released the 15-point plan, reports indicated that Trump released it without first consulting Israel.
After the plan was released, a senior US official gave an off-the-record briefing to reporters and implied that Trump would be “very, very disappointed” if Israel did not follow the new plan.
Miller stressed, “Donald Trump has said and done several things for Israel, and for Netanyahu, that none of his predecessors have done. No one has spoken to an Israeli prime minister the way Trump has spoken to Netanyahu. No one has opened a dialogue with Hamas without first consulting the Israelis.”
All of that is unprecedented, Miller told DW. “But whether Donald Trump is willing to bear significant and serious consequences for US-Israel relations is a different matter,” he told DW.
That could include measures such as cutting or restricting US aid or intelligence cooperation, as well as not defending Israel at the UN and other forums. However, both Miller and Shehada stressed that none of these measures have been implemented.
“If you stand in the way of Donald Trump getting something he really wants, that can put you in a very bad and dangerous position,” Miller said.
“So the question is, what is so important to Trump that he would be willing to really pressure Israel? Perhaps the opportunity to normalise Israel-Saudi relations, if there is a real breakthrough in the Gaza conflict.”
But according to Miller, current conditions are still very far from that scenario. It is unlikely that Trump will do more than issue statements. The former US State Department adviser also assessed that Trump is likely to focus his influence more on avoiding conflict with Iran.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/can-trump-pressure-israel-to-accept-the-gaza-peace-plan-1785984745)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8606375/mampukah-trump-tekan-israel-agar-terima-rencana-damai-gaza), translated from Indonesian