By Todd Callahan
By Todd Callahan
Since 2000, national cement consumption has experienced a strong recovery and the sector as a whole is quite vibrant. Despite temporary declines in growth on parts of Java and Bali, consumption is robust in Riau, Kalimantan, Papua and many other outer islands.
According to the Indonesian Cement Association, the industry enjoyed another high-growth year in 2002, with domestic consumption topping just over 27 million metric tons. Another positive sign is that cement sales are now close to pre-crisis levels. For the longer term, as the restructuring of the Indonesian economy continues, the industry can expect to benefit from even more growth.
Beyond a slowly improving economy, a crucial factor driving the rejuvenation of the sector has been foreign investment, more of which the country urgently requires if it is to get back on its feet. Since the late 1990s, four of the world's top producers - Germany's Heidelberger, Switzerland's Holcim, France's Lafarge and Mexico's Cemex - have bought into the Indonesian cement industry.
Their interest in Indonesia is a part of their overall strategy of consolidation and diversification geographically into developing markets with high-growth potential. Three have already acquired majority shareholdings in Indonesian companies while Cemex has purchased a substantial minority position in state-owned Semen Gresik Group.
Heidelberger has acquired majority control of PT Indocement, once the country's largest private producer. Formerly an important asset in the Salim Group's portfolio of companies, Indocement was pledged to the Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency (IBRA) to repay the government for its bailout of the group's bank at the height of the financial crisis.
Heidelberger was named the winner when IBRA sought to divest its stake holding in Indocement. Today Indocement boasts an installed production capacity of 15.65 million metric tons per year and a domestic market share of approximately 32 percent.
Holcim acquired majority control of Semen Cibinong as a part of the Indonesian company's efforts to restructure more than US$1 billion in debts. Through a complicated restructuring agreement, Holcim agreed to pump over US$300 million into the troubled firm and assume responsibility for some of its obligations in return for a majority stake. Today Semen Cibinong has an installed capacity of 9.7 million metric tons per year and a domestic market share of approximately 13 percent.
Lafarge acquired majority control of Semen Andalas after its takeover of Blue Circle. Although Lafarge has operated in Indonesia since the early 1980s, its holdings in the cement sector remain relatively modest. Semen Andalas is a small Sumatra-based producer with an installed capacity of approximately 1.4 million metric tons per annum and a domestic market share hovering around 4 percent.
Mexico's Cemex owns a 25.5 percent holding in Semen Gresik Group, which operates three units in East Java, South Sulawesi and West Sumatra. Although Cemex would like to acquire a majority stake in the firm, the sale has not occurred because of opposition from pressure groups linked to top managers at the unit level, especially in West Sumatra.
Regrettably, the government, as the majority stakeholder in the Semen Gresik Group, has been unable to even force an extraordinary shareholders meeting at its own Semen Padang unit. In a coup against central government authority, a local court in the West Sumatra provincial capital Padang has prevented the meeting from taking place. The case is now awaiting a final decision from the Supreme Court.
Until the government deals decisively with vested interests, privatization of Semen Gresik is likely to remain unfinished.
All of these investments are sure to have a positive impact on the future development of Indonesia's cement industry. Prior to acquisition, it is a sad fact that some of these companies lacked important elements of corporate governance and performance accountability. The reason this happened is because many commissioners, directors and top managers who controlled these firms owed their positions to patronage rather than competence.
It is hoped that international players will introduce higher levels of corporate governance and management accountability. Another tangible way the industry benefits is from the worldwide trading networks of the foreign investors. Specifically, there will be more of an opportunity to export cement at a time when the local industry is still over capacity.
Furthermore, foreign investors bring with them fresh capital and access to state-of-the-art production and management information technology. This will boost competitiveness and modernize the domestic industry.
Finally, despite concerns that these investments would exact social costs such as increased unemployment, there have been no massive layoffs at any of the companies. It was an argument purely grounded in fear, and, in fact, job security for the average worker is better today than it was before the acquisitions occurred.
With respect to concern these investments will lead to private monopolies that fleece the Indonesian people, the fear is genuine but it is being manipulated by vested interests. The foundation for this anxiety is that predatory monopolies were long a feature of Soeharto's Indonesia until his resignation in 1998. Suspicion toward the private sector is comprehensible because examples abound of corporate Indonesia acting against the interests of the people.
That said, the "foreign ownership equals monopoly" argument does not hold up because monopolies ultimately cannot exist without the permission of government. If the government focuses its attention on regulating industries, this is a non-issue.
In the United States, for example, more than 80 percent of the cement industry is in foreign hands but prices remain low because the government ensures fair competition. If the Indonesian people do not have confidence that this will happen, then it is up to the local media, NGO community and other pressure groups to make sure that monopolistic behavior does not surface.
Privatization is admittedly a controversial issue in Indonesia. Privatization itself is merely an economic prescription stemming from shock therapy and the Harvard view that the private sector was inherently good for parts of the world like Eastern Europe. Nonetheless, from China and Vietnam down to Indonesia, government officials are not so sure that breaking iron rice bowls, confronting unionized workforces and tackling interest groups is necessarily a good idea.
For the present government, there is the added risk that pushing a privatization like Semen Gresik t0o aggressively will make President Megawati Soekarnoputri vulnerable to political attacks in the run-up to next year's general election. That said, the economic argument in support of privatization is indisputable. If one wears a longer eyepiece and does good, comparative analyses, the evidence is clear that the government, industry, employees and other stakeholders would be better off if the Semen Gresik Group were privatized.
The overall trend in the Indonesian cement industry is positive and strong growth is certain to continue as the country recovers. As a means to strengthen the domestic industry, foreign investors should be welcomed as partners and catalysts of change to enhance performance, ensure a competitive market and, not insignificantly, to spur additional investment in Indonesia.
Indocement
Cibinong
Andalas
Semen Gresik Group
Multinational Cement Firm's Stakeholding
61.7%
77.3%
88.0%
25.5%
Cement Production Capacity per Year (MMT)
15.65
9.70
1.40
17.25
Cement Production Volume in 2002 (MMT)
9.37
4.12
1.12
14.13
Domestic Sales Volume in 2002 (MMT)
8.73
3.52
1.11
11.86
Export Sales Volume in 2002 (MMT)
- Cement
0.86
0.96
0.00
1.92
- Clinker
1.44
1.60
0.00
0.35
Market Share in Domestic Market
32%
13%
4%
44%
Todd Callahan is a Senior Technical Advisor at PT Jasa Cita, a Jakarta-based research consultancy associated with CastleAsia.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/by-todd-callahan-1447893297-1364911)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post