Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Business Expansion Does Not Always Pay Off: Investors Must Understand ROIC

| | Source: pasbana.com Translated from Indonesian | Investment
Business Expansion Does Not Always Pay Off: Investors Must Understand ROIC
Image: pasbana.com

Companies that regularly expand often appear promising. They build new factories, increase production capacity and continue to grow profits. But behind this growth story lies an important question that investors often overlook: does expansion actually create added value for shareholders?

In equity investing, a larger business is not necessarily a more valuable one. Every rupiah used for expansion has an opportunity cost. A company must generate a return higher than that available from alternative investments with a comparable level of risk.

Understanding value creation in equity investing

Imagine an investor has Rp30 billion. The money could be placed in an investment instrument yielding 8% a year, but instead the investor chooses to put it into a company that is developing its business.

That decision is worthwhile only if the expansion generates an adequate return. The following three simple examples illustrate the point.

  • Value-destroying expansion: A company invests Rp30 billion and generates only Rp1.6 billion in additional profit. The return is about 5.3%, below the 8% benchmark. The business has grown, but the capital deployed has not generated a commensurate return.

  • Value-creating expansion: With an investment of Rp20 billion, a company generates an additional Rp2.4 billion in profit, producing a 12% return. If this reflects a sustainable return on capital, the expansion could increase the company’s economic value.

  • Break-even expansion: A company spends Rp15 billion and earns an additional Rp1.2 billion in profit. The return is 8%, equal to the benchmark. In this example, the company has not generated economic value above its cost of capital.

ROIC and cost of capital: two important indicators

In fundamental share analysis, two concepts help investors assess the quality of a company’s expansion.

Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) measures a company’s ability to generate profits from the capital invested in it. The cost of capital is the minimum return a company must generate to compensate for its financing costs and investment risks.

  • If ROIC is higher than the cost of capital, the company may be creating economic value.

  • If ROIC equals the cost of capital, the company is earning a return equivalent to its cost of capital.

  • If ROIC is lower than the cost of capital, the company risks destroying economic value if the situation persists.

In practice, ROIC should be calculated using after-tax operating profit relative to invested capital, rather than simply dividing the increase in net profit by capital expenditure.

A lesson from Warren Buffett

In his 1984 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, Warren Buffett stressed that retained earnings should be reinvested when the prospects are reasonable for generating greater value for shareholders than other uses of the funds.

This thinking is relevant when analysing companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX). Revenue growth, factory construction and increases in net profit should all be assessed in light of the quality of the returns on capital.

Investors can review annual reports and financial statements, capital expenditure (capex), operating cash flow, and a company’s ROIC trend over several years. They should also compare returns on capital before and after expansion to see whether new investments are genuinely productive.

In short, do not buy shares merely because a company is growing larger. Check whether each rupiah invested can generate a return that exceeds the cost of capital.

The more carefully investors assess value creation, the stronger the basis for their investment decisions. Investors should improve their financial literacy and make a habit of reading financial statements before buying shares.

More from 25 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/business-expansion-does-not-always-pay-off-investors-must-understand-roic-1792907418)
Originally published by pasbana.com (https://www.pasbana.com/2026/10/ekspansi-bisnis-belum-tentu-menguntungkan-investor-saham-wajib-tahu-roic.html), translated from Indonesian
Print