Budiman Bayu's Legal Team Seeks to Nullify Graft Indictment
The legal team for defendant Budiman Bayu Prasojo has requested that the panel of judges at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court declare the public prosecutor’s indictment null and void, or at least inadmissible. The request was submitted through a notice of objection (exception) read out during the trial on Tuesday (4/8).
In this case, Budiman is accused of receiving gratuities during his tenure as Head of the Customs Intelligence Section. The prosecutor indicted him under Article 12B in conjunction with Article 18 of Law Number 31 of 1999 on the Eradication of Criminal Acts of Corruption, as amended by Law Number 20 of 2001, linked to Article 127 paragraph (1) of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code.
In their exception, the legal team stressed that the objection was not aimed at disputing the evidence, but rather at testing whether the indictment met the formal and material requirements stipulated in criminal procedural law. According to the defence, the prosecutor’s indictment was not drafted carefully, clearly, and completely because it mixed various events, parties, transactions, currencies, and forms of participation without specifically detailing the acts allegedly committed by Budiman.
‘The indictment does not separate the defendant’s actions from the actions of other parties, so the defendant must refute all fund flows and actions of other parties without knowing the actual boundaries of the individual charges,’ the advocacy team stated while reading the exception in court. The defence highlighted the indictment linking Budiman with several other parties, including Riza, Resi Suprianto, and Orlando Hamonangan, regarding alleged gratuity receipts from September 2024 to January 2026. They argued the prosecutor did not detail which transactions were directly received by Budiman, who controlled the money, who enjoyed the proceeds, or the portion of receipts personally attributed to the defendant.
Furthermore, the advocacy team argued that the element of ‘related to the position and contrary to obligations or duties’ in Article 12B of the Corruption Law was merely stated as a conclusion without explaining the relationship between the gifts, the authority of the position, and the official actions allegedly taken by the defendant. They contended the prosecutor also failed to explain what assistance was requested by the giver of the gratuity, Budiman’s authority to fulfil that request, or the specific rules and obligations allegedly violated.
In the exception, the legal team also questioned the inclusion of Article 127 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code. They argued that the provision concerning the concurrence of criminal acts cannot be applied without explaining which criminal acts stand alone and the basis for combining all the alleged acts. The advocacy team also criticised the use of the phrase ‘whether acting alone or together’ in the indictment, arguing that this formulation mixes two different forms of criminal liability—as a sole perpetrator and as a participant—without explaining the legal construction used by the prosecutor for each event.
Additionally, the legal team assessed that the inclusion of Article 18 of the Corruption Law regarding additional penalties cannot stand alone because it is accessory to the main offence. Therefore, they argued, if the indictment under Article 12B is deemed not to meet the requirements, the application of Article 18 also loses its legal basis.
Based on all these arguments, the legal team requested that the panel of judges accept the defendant’s exception, declare the indictment does not meet material requirements because it was not drafted carefully, clearly, and completely, and declare the indictment null and void or at least inadmissible. They also requested the panel declare that Article 127 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code cannot be applied in this case and order that the examination of the main case not proceed based on the existing indictment.
After the reading of the exception, the Chief Judge stated that the notice of objection had been received and made part of the case file. The trial was then adjourned until the following week, with the agenda of hearing the public prosecutor’s response to the exception submitted by the defendant.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/budiman-bayus-legal-team-seeks-to-nullify-graft-indictment-1785822642)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/918017/tim-kuasa-hukum-budiman-bayu-minta-dakwaan-gratifikasi-jaksa-dinyatakan-batal-demi-hukum), translated from Indonesian