Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Part 1 of 2

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Part 1 of 2

U.S.-Indonesia relationship enters new era

Ali Alatas, Former Foreign Minister, Jakarta

To begin with, I think it can be said with certainty that
relations between the United States and Indonesia today are sound
and solid, despite the occasional frictions, misunderstandings
and misperceptions of one another that we have had in the past
and, I am sure, will continue to have in the future.

It is by no means a narrow relationship but one that
encompasses a wide range of issues and concerns. It is a
relationship that is based on shared democratic values and common
interest in global and regional stability and prosperity, and a
firm will to confront common challenges. It is also a long-
standing relationship that has its roots in the history of
Indonesia, in which the U.S. has time and again played an
important role.

In the early 1990s, with the Cold War melted down and
Indonesia no longer so important as a buffer against real and
perceived communist threats in the region, the new issues of
human rights, labor rights, democracy and good governance drove a
wedge between the U.S. and Indonesia.

Very soon after President Megawati came to office,
international terrorism inflicted the tragedy of Sept. 11 on the
U.S., and one of her very first official acts was to fly to
Washington to offer Indonesia's condolences and support for the
war on international terrorism that President George W. Bush was
just beginning to wage.

As can be seen, the history of U.S.-Indonesia relations has
had its high and low points, but as earlier noted, it has
remained basically sound and solid -- capable of overcoming the
irritants, points of friction and unresolved problems that
occasionally mar that relationship.

In the bilateral context, these irritants are well known.
These include the paralysis that military-to-military relations
between the two countries have suffered in the past several
years. Basically, the American view appears to be that the
Indonesian military is not reforming itself fast enough. On the
other hand, the Indonesian view is that considerable progress has
actually been achieved in reforming the military, but it is not
being appreciated.

To many Americans, it is a matter of continuing concern that
the case of the fatal shooting of two American citizens and one
Indonesian in the province of Papua in August 2002 is still
unresolved.

On the other hand, it is quite annoying to Indonesians that
their countrymen living in the U.S., who are 16 years or older,
are required to register with the Immigration and Naturalization
Service, and be fingerprinted, photographed and interviewed under
oath -- a requirement that is not imposed on other Southeast
Asian nationals.

And those advisories warning travelers against going to
Indonesia are not only reinforcing the erroneous image of
Indonesia as a "nest of terrorism" but a definitely hurting the
local tourist industry on which a huge number of our citizens
depend for a living.

As to the overall image, the two sides have of one another,
Indonesians often complain about what they perceive as American
"high handedness and arrogance", a tendency to make others do
their bidding. In this, they are not alone. On the other hand,
Americans often express their impatience and irritation at what
they see as the slow pace and hesitation in which Indonesia
tackles such problems as corruption, legal reform and the need
for good governance.

In many cases, problems like these can perhaps be ascribed to
what has been described as the "asymmetry" in the relationship
between the U.S. and Indonesia. One is the only superpower in the
world today; the other is a developing country going through a
difficult and delicate transition.

Politically and economically, Indonesia is more dependent on
the U.S. than vice versa -- and this often gives rise to a sense
of frustration and helplessness, and a sensitivity to every
affront real or imagined. This reminds me of what the French
moralist, La Rochefoucauld once said: "We always like those who
admire us, but we do not always like those whom we admire."

On the other hand, Sept. 11 has brought about a paradigm shift
in the U.S. An acute sense of danger has driven the American
leadership to rethink every conventional wisdom about national
security and the relationship of the U.S. with the rest of the
world. This has not made U.S.-Indonesian relations any easier to
manage.

This reconfirms the point I have always stressed, that U.S.-
Indonesian relations cannot be viewed in their bilateral context
only. For these relations are inevitably influenced by the larger
global and regional issues and developments while, conversely,
they can also positively or negatively influence international
and regional developments and trends.

The U.S. has always been the major power in the world and is
now the single superpower. But never before has it so openly
exercised its power in a unilateral way as it is doing now, post
Sept. 11. Hence, a major issue today is what the international
community views as U.S. unilateralism and policies that flow from
it.

Moreover, out of this unilateralism, new concepts and policies
have evolved, such as the notion of pre-emptive strike or pre-
emptive war. It has also resulted in the UN being increasingly
sidelined in its role to safeguard international security. Thus,
what is seen as U.S. unilateralism is now pitted against the
strong commitment of Indonesia and many other nations to
multilateralism. And this will inevitably color our bilateral
relationship.

Another issue that has given rise to misperceptions of one
another are the differences of approach in our common fight
against international terrorism. The U.S. and Indonesia are in
full agreement that international terrorism is an assault against
all humanity and should therefore be unequivocally condemned and
universally opposed.

Likewise, unilaterally inspired action should not be the
preferred option, but rather multilaterally concerted effort
which, we believe, should ideally and most appropriately be
directed and coordinated by the United Nations.

Thus, the concerns we expressed when the attacks were launched
on Afghanistan and Iraq, were not because of our love for the
Taliban or the regime of Saddam Hussein, but rather the
manifestation of our deep concern that a threat that was clearly
directed against the security of the entire international
community, in terms of the UN Charter prescriptions, was not
being met by concerted action, authorized and organized within
the framework of the UN.

As we all know, Indonesia has taken the brunt of a series of
terrorist attacks, inter alia in Bali and in the Marriott Hotel
in Jakarta. We can be counted upon, therefore, to vigorously
pursue the fight against terrorism.

However, we will not and cannot abandon due process of law and
the essential guarantees of democracy to which we have committed
ourselves. The pace at which Indonesia conducts its fight against
terrorism should therefore be seen in this light and not
misperceived as lack of resolve.

Attacking the physical manifestations of terrorism is indeed
necessary in the short term. In the longer term, however, the
only way to defeat terrorism is to remove its underlying causes.
Terrorism arises from a sense of injustice and alienation, from
ignorance and prejudice.

It is fanaticism which feeds on grievances, hatred born of
despair. These can also be no doubt that abject poverty,
backwardness and especially the glaring social inequities that
accompany those conditions are the seedbeds of the anger and
irrational hatred which erode respect for the value of human
life. Obviously also, it is totally wrong to associate
international terrorism with any particular religion or group of
people.

A third range of issues that has influenced and will continue
to influence our bilateral relations, concerns developments in
the Middle East.

The problems and consequences arising from U.S. policies in
post-war Iraq, in the Middle East region in general and on the
Palestine-Israeli conflict in particular, will also, I believe,
exercise a significant impact on our bilateral relationship,
depending on how these policies develop.

For example, one of the outstanding problems which have always
been a cause of mutual irritation and friction relates to the
Palestine-Israeli conflict. If in the post-Iraq war situation,
America chooses to devote serious and even-handed efforts to the
comprehensive and just solution of the Palestine-Israel conflict,
which at this point means putting equal pressure to Israel as
well as the Palestinian leadership to faithfully implement the
"roadmap", then I think we will not only be closer to a solution
in the conflict, but also closer to better relations overall and
better safeguarding of U.S. interests in the region and in the
world at large.

But if the U.S. Government continues to be seen as being
partial towards Sharon, even after the many concessions given by
the Palestinians, then I am afraid this will not only continue to
affect negatively our bilateral relationship but also U.S.
relations with the Muslim and Non-Aligned world in general.

U.S. policies post-Sept. 11 will also have consequences in the
economic field and in the bilateral economic relations between
our two countries. It will get progressively more difficult to
overcome the security measures and inhibitions that the U.S. will
apply, not only in relation to Indonesia but to other trading
nations as well. This will affect our exports and our economic
relationship with the U.S.

This article was condensed from a speech made by former
foreign minister Ali Alatas at the observation of the 10th
anniversary of the United States-Indonesia Society (USINDO) in
Washington on March 23.

More from 31 March 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/bpart-1-of-2b-1447893297-1476718)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print