Between Profit and Trust: Testing the Ethics of Price Mark-ups in Business
In business, transactions do not always take place directly between a seller and a buyer. A third party may act as an intermediary, helping to source goods, arrange purchases, provide services or manage business needs. In these arrangements, a difference can arise between the budget provided and the price actually paid. In everyday practice, this difference is often referred to as a “price mark-up”.
Making a profit in business is not, in itself, prohibited. Islam permits trade and profit when they are pursued properly, with the parties’ consent, and without deception or abuse of trust. Therefore, not every additional charge can immediately be considered fraudulent. What needs to be examined is the type of contract, the position of each party, the transparency of information and the agreement on how profit will be earned.
From the perspective of Islamic economics, price mark-ups should be assessed in light of the principles of justice (al-’adl), honesty (ash-shidq), trust (amanah) and public benefit (maslahah). The issue is not simply whether there is a price difference, but whether the profit was obtained legitimately, is known to and approved by the relevant parties, and does not involve tadlis (deception), gharar (excessive uncertainty), risywah (bribery) or the wrongful appropriation of property.
This article examines price mark-ups in business activities generally, including the purchase of goods, the provision of services and the use of intermediaries. Its aim is to distinguish profits permitted under Islamic law from concealed practices that can undermine trust and confidence.
Price mark-ups from the perspective of Islamic law
The term “price mark-up” can refer to several different practices. In one case, someone buys goods first and then resells them at a higher price. In another, someone is asked to purchase goods using another party’s money. There are also intermediaries who bring buyers and sellers together in return for a commission. These three arrangements are not necessarily governed by the same rules, because the contracts and responsibilities of the parties differ.
Such practices are not automatically prohibited. Profits from sales can be permissible, as can payment for intermediary services, provided the contract is clear and no important information is deliberately concealed. However, keeping part of money entrusted for a purchase without the owner’s knowledge is a different matter: the person receiving the funds is acting as a trustee, rather than using the money for personal gain.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/between-profit-and-trust-testing-the-ethics-of-price-mark-ups-in-business-1794444683)
Originally published by Republika (https://opini.republika.co.id/berita/tod4ti483/antara-cuan-dan-amanah-menguji-etika-titip-harga-dalam-dunia-bisnis), translated from Indonesian