Being Asked for Your ID and Photographed When Entering a Building May Breach the Law
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — Handing over a national identity card (KTP) at a front-office desk or having one’s face scanned before entering an office building or public facility has become a familiar sight. The procedure is often compulsory, with visitors barred from entering if they do not bring or hand over identification.
But behind these standard security measures lies a serious legal question. The collection of personal data may breach privacy rules, specifically Indonesia’s Personal Data Protection Law (UU PDP).
Parasurama Pamungkas, a researcher at the Institute for Policy Research and Advocacy (ELSAM), said collecting identity data on entry to a building often violates basic data-protection principles because it is not relevant to the activity being carried out.
“Collecting personal data that is not actually relevant to the activity we are doing, such as entering a tower or registering an account, is a form of non-compliance by the data controller with personal data-protection principles,” Parasurama told CNBC Indonesia.
He said data controllers fail to meet the requirement for lawful processing when they collect more data than is necessary for the stated purpose, provide little transparency and risk using the information for purposes unrelated to a visitor’s presence in the building.
Although Indonesia enacted the UU PDP in 2022, with strict penalties for institutions that fail to comply, implementation has stalled. The government has yet to establish the personal data-protection supervisory authority, which was supposed to be operational by 17 October 2024.
When does this practice breach the UU PDP?
Separately, Pratama Persadha, chairman of the Institute for Cybersecurity and Communications Research (CISSReC), said the practice of exchanging an identity card for entry does not automatically constitute a legal violation. It depends on how the building manager handles the data.
Simply glancing at an identity card for visual verification carries a very different risk from photocopying or scanning it, storing it in a database, or retaining it indefinitely.
Under the UU PDP, data collection must be limited, specific, lawful and transparent.
“So when someone is asked to hand over or scan their identity card to enter a building, it should first be explained who the data controller is, what the data will be used for, how long it will be stored, who can access it and when it will be deleted,” Pratama said.
He also stressed the importance of data minimisation. If the sole purpose is to confirm that someone is a registered visitor, building managers have no right to copy and retain all the sensitive information displayed on the identity card.
Real data-leak risks and the rise of AI
From a cybersecurity perspective, Alfons Tanujaya, a cybersecurity expert at Vaksincom, warned that selfies and identity cards collected haphazardly are not official identification instruments recognised by the Directorate General of Population and Civil Registration (Dukcapil).
The security of the storage server rests entirely with the building manager. If it fails to protect the data, the consequences of a breach could be severe.
“If it isn’t stored securely, then if the data leaks, that’s it,” Alfons said.
He warned of an even greater threat in the age of artificial intelligence (AI): leaked facial images and identity-card data could easily be misused by criminals. “With the photo, the face, the selfie — AI can be used to manipulate it,” he said.
Alternative solutions and the public’s rights
In light of these risks, experts urged building managers to find safer, more privacy-friendly verification methods without restricting the public’s access to facilities. ELSAM said privacy should be the default and built into systems by design.
While the public waits for the regulator to establish an official supervisory body, people are encouraged to remain vigilant and to question the need to hand over identity data whenever they visit a public facility or office building.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/being-asked-for-your-id-and-photographed-when-entering-a-building-may-breach-the-law-1793620249)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20261102132245-37-781528/diminta-ktp-dan-difoto-saat-masuk-gedung-ternyata-melanggar-uu), translated from Indonesian