Begal Bounty Policy Must Not Displace Law Enforcement Authority
Abdul Fickar Hadjar, a criminal law lecturer at Trisakti University, views the bounty policy for catching robbers, initiated by West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi, as an effort to encourage public participation in maintaining security rather than an invitation to take over the function of law enforcement.
Fickar stressed that maintaining public security and order is fundamentally the responsibility of the state, carried out by law enforcement and security apparatus. Nevertheless, the state can, and indeed should, involve the community in efforts to safeguard neighbourhood security.
“Fundamentally, maintaining security and order is the state’s task, carried out by law enforcement and security authorities. However, in the life of the state and society, the state can, and indeed must, involve the community in participating in maintaining security together,” Fickar told Media Indonesia on Sunday (26/7).
According to him, the greatest challenge in involving the public is ensuring that such participation does not turn into acts of violence against perpetrators. In practice, members of the public often overstep the mark by committing assault when criminals are caught in the act.
On that basis, Fickar considered that the idea of rewarding residents who help catch criminals must be understood as encouragement for the public to hand perpetrators over to the authorities, not to punish them themselves.
“It is in that context that West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi’s idea must be understood, namely encouraging the public not to take the law into their own hands and to surrender perpetrators to law enforcement, by providing an incentive in the form of a prize for residents who help catch criminals. From this perspective, the policy can actually be understood as an effort to prevent vigilante actions,” he said.
Nevertheless, Fickar reminded that the policy does not remove criminal liability if abuse occurs during the arrest process. Excessive use of violence, wrongful arrests, or assault resulting in injury or death can still be prosecuted.
“If during the arrest there is excessive use of violence, wrongful arrest, or assault resulting in the victim suffering injuries or death, then such acts must still be held accountable under criminal law,” he asserted.
He also explained that criminal law does not only consider the consequences caused, but also assesses the context of an event. Criminal liability will be influenced by various factors, such as whether the act was carried out in self-defence, out of negligence, deliberately, or in the course of carrying out an order.
“These factors will influence a person’s criminal liability, from the severity of the sentence to the possibility of the perpetrator being acquitted or released from all legal charges,” he said.
In addition, Fickar emphasised that the bounty policy must be positioned as an instrument of crime prevention, not as a substitute for law enforcement by the authorities. According to him, the policy’s main objective is to prevent the spread of criminal acts while providing protection to the public.
“The appeal must be placed as a preventive step to prevent the spread of crime that disrupts public security and order, which is fundamentally the state’s responsibility,” he said.
“On the one hand, this policy is a form of state protection towards its citizens. On the other hand, the policy is also a preventive effort so that criminal acts do not spread further,” Fickar continued.
Furthermore, he considered the policy also has the potential to create a deterrent effect on would-be criminals.
“The knock-on effect is to create a deterrent effect on potential perpetrators of crime, who are basically also part of society,” said Fickar.
As previously reported, West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi launched a bounty scheme offering Rp5 million to Rp50 million for residents who succeed in catching perpetrators of robbery, bag-snatching, theft or mugging alive, to then be handed over to the police. The policy is intended to increase public participation in maintaining security.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/begal-bounty-policy-must-not-displace-law-enforcement-authority-1785063026)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/914946/sayembara-begal-jangan-geser-kewenangan-aparat-penegakan-hukum), translated from Indonesian