Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Done

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Done

How insurance companies should weather the storm

Mahendra Gautama
Contributor
Jakarta

A "perfect storm" may be the appropriate phrase to describe
the current predicament of insurance companies worldwide.

One of the reasons for this is the failure of most mergers and
acquisitions, which started in the early 1990s.

This was confirmed by a survey conducted by the consultancy
company McKinsey in 2003 in its report titled Assessing Insurance
Deals, on the major failures of many American and European
insurance companies in their efforts to increase the value of
their shares.

There were 237 mergers and acquisitions between 1990 and 2001
for a value of US$75 billion, but they were only able to increase
shareholder earnings by 1.6 percent for the short-term period and
2.4 percent in the long term.

The turbulence was worsened by the Sept. 11 tragedy that
compelled global insurance companies to pay out claims of US$40.2
billion. This blow to the insurance industry caused nine out of
10 leading insurance companies major losses and reduced the
entire industry's capital, as reported by Oxford Metrica and Aon
Corporation in Insurance and the Stock Market: The Asset Test.

The second factor that contributes to further difficulties is
a change in the "power" between insurance carriers and insurance
brokers.

Traditionally, insurance brokers -- the backbone of insurance
companies -- play a vital role in acquiring clients. Apart from
their astuteness in negotiation, they are also frequently relied
upon by many clients to design their risk program management. For
all this, they receive commissions calculated from premiums paid
by their clients.

Today the situation has changed. Many major corporations are
designing their own internal risk managements. This has prompted
insurance brokers to adapt and enhance their consultancy skills,
which leads to more income directly from clients due to their
larger role as consultants compared to the conventional
commissions. The 2002 report issued by McKinsey, Brokers Versus
Insurers, indicated that most insurance brokers with their newer
role have beaten the insurance companies in relation to the
earning ratio by about 65 percent.

The third factor is the emergence of new competitors, like
smaller and middle-sized companies on the Internet and, of
course, the ubiquitous banks with their large base of clients.
These new competitors are aware that the transaction cost of
insurance companies is high: as much as 35 percent of premiums or
$140 billion. With a more cost-effective strategy, these new
entrants only need a third of the transaction cost.

The question that lurks in the minds of most CEOs of global
insurance companies is whether it is still possible to survive
and make a reasonable profit.

There are some classic but still promising marketing
strategies to be adhered to. Obviously, the foremost task is to
increase the level of customer satisfaction. As reported by
Accenture in 2001 in Unlocking the Value in Claims, claim
settlement is number one in creating customer satisfaction. The
report indicated that 94 percent of consumers said the speed of
claim settlement is the top priority, while 74 percent said the
nominal amount of settlements is another important factor.

It was also reported that close to 90 percent of customers
that were happy with the above two factors preferred to remain
loyal to the same company. Seventy-eight percent of them even
said they would recommend the company based on these satisfactory
elements.

The next step for insurance companies to take is either to
become a giant-sized company with a worldwide reputation or a
very specialized company. One example of such an alliance is that
between Allianz of Germany, AGF of France, Generali of Italy, AMB
of Germany, AXA also from France and the Royal Guardian Exchange
from England. This alliance is a "dream come true" about a single
European market.

Naturally, this global conglomeration or alliance is offering
the very best of its resources, product features and their
combined strength is meant to serve clients more efficiently in
face of current competition. Hence, for smaller insurance
companies the option is to specialize and provide specialized and
highly customized products.

In England, for example, newly specialized insurance companies
have cropped up, like the one offering policies for musical
instruments and another specially handling Chinese restaurants.
Such specialists are required to have a greater focus on the
seemingly smaller segments, but provide a full-range of
personalized product features that cater to clients' needs on a
one-to-one basis.

It seems that to reduce the impact of today's situation, the
challenge for insurance companies is to roll up their sleeves and
position their companies correctly through the right choices. A
customer-oriented mind-set is one of the wisest choices to adopt.

More from 30 June 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/bdoneb-1447899208-1326967)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print