Banyuwangi Judge Given Two-Year Suspension from Judicial Duties for Sexual Misconduct
A judge at Banyuwangi Religious Court who was seconded as a judicial judge at Surabaya Religious High Court, identified by the initial K, has been given a two-year suspension from judicial duties.
At a hearing of the Judicial Honour Council (MKH), convened by the Judicial Commission (KY) and the Supreme Court (MA) on Monday (19 October), K was found to have left the office during working hours in an official car to travel with a woman identified as N. The encounter culminated in sex outside marriage.
“The council imposes a severe sanction on the reported judge: a two-year suspension from judicial duties at the Religious High Court, during which his judicial position allowance will not be paid,” MKH chairman Noor Edi Yono said in a written statement circulated by the KY public relations office on Tuesday (20 October).
According to the Supreme Court’s Supervisory Agency (Bawas) investigation, K and N first met at a school reunion and a celebration of K’s birthday in 2021. At the time, K was deputy head of Dompu Religious Court. After that meeting, they frequently communicated and shared details of their personal lives, including the fact that both were divorced.
In February 2022, N came to Dompu and K picked her up. They then travelled in an official car during working hours to a hotel, where they had sex outside marriage.
N said the encounter had been forced and sought accountability from K. However, K denied responsibility, saying he already had a prospective wife, identified as NMS, whom he subsequently married in September 2022. N reported K to the Supreme Court’s Supervisory Agency in October 2022.
In his defence, K said he had obtained N’s telephone number from a friend, identified as F, in 2021. F had suggested that they get to know each other. K said that after they met at the reunion, N began contacting him more frequently.
K said N contacted him to arrange a meeting in Dompu and asked him to pick her up because she had no acquaintances in the area. When he collected her, she was wet from the rain.
K claimed that he suggested N change her clothes at a mosque, but she refused and asked him to take her to a hotel instead.
K also said N’s family and child later contacted him and asked him not to contact her again, as they hoped she would reconcile with her former husband. K said he agreed and blocked N’s number.
After the complaint was filed, K was questioned. He said that he and N had met for mediation, agreed to settle the matter and withdraw the complaint.
However, K said his superior had prohibited the withdrawal of the complaint, fearing the matter could escalate further. K said he followed that instruction.
At the MKH hearing, K called two character witnesses: his biological elder sister, identified as SN, and his wife, NMS. Their testimony was deemed unable to mitigate the breach because neither had direct knowledge of the events under review. K also submitted several documentary items, including a statement that he and N had reached a settlement.
The Indonesian Judges Association (IKAHI), in its defence submission, asked the MKH to impose a lighter sanction. Among the considerations it cited were that K had remarried and had a young child.
In its ruling, the MKH said K’s claim that N had initiated and invited him to have sex outside marriage could not be accepted because it contradicted the findings of the investigation at Mataram Religious High Court.
Factors mitigating K’s case included his admission that sex outside marriage had taken place, his co-operation during the investigation, his remorse and his promise not to repeat the conduct. The MKH also took into account his service as a judge since 2008 and his good record as a judicial judge.
The aggravating factor was that the conduct took place while K was serving as deputy head of Dompu Religious Court.
“The council rules, first, to accept the reported judge’s defence in part. Second, to amend the recommendation of the Supreme Court Supervisory Agency: K breached the Joint Regulation of the Supreme Court and Judicial Commission No. 02/PB/MA/IX/2012 and No. 02/PB/P.KY/09/2012 on Guidelines for Enforcing the Code of Ethics and Conduct for Judges, section C on acting wisely and prudently, point 3, and upholding dignity, point 7,” Noor Edi Yono said.
Representing the Supreme Court as members of the MKH hearing were Supreme Court Justices Muhayah and Rahmi Mulyani. The Judicial Commission was represented by its deputy chairman, Desmihardi, and members Abhan, F. Willem Saija and Setyawan Hartono.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/banyuwangi-judge-given-two-year-suspension-from-judicial-duties-for-sexual-misconduct-1792486336)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261020142011-12-1417517/berbuat-asusila-hakim-di-banyuwangi-disanksi-nonpalu-2-tahun), translated from Indonesian