Banking developments in 1996 and policy directions for 1997
Banking developments in 1996 and policy directions for 1997
The following article is an excerpt from an address delivered
by Bank Indonesia Governor J. Soedradjad Djiwandono at an annual
bankers' meeting on Jan. 8. This is the first of two articles.
JAKARTA: In recent years, our economy has witnessed
significant developments amidst a dynamic world economic
environment. New sources of finance for economic activities have
emerged. The business world is no longer dependent only on the
financial services offered by the banking system, but can avail
itself of the financial system as a whole, including finance
companies and other non-bank financial institutions. Non-bank
financial institutions such as mutual funds and multi finance
companies are gaining a greater role as financial intermediaries,
in so doing competing with banks in the financing of various
economic activities.
This is supported by the growing trend of securitization, or
the process of integrating operations of banks with those of
securities houses. Similarly, recent advances in technology have
encouraged the development of new payment instruments such as
electronic money as a corollary of the effort to build a more
efficient payments system. Derivatives have also widened the
scope of financial services that supplement existing banking
products.
A factor contributing to the significant progress in our
economy and particularly in the financial sector is the global shift
towards liberalized world trade enhanced by a closer regional
cooperation. Several milestones have been achieved in this area. In
their meeting in Singapore last December, the ministers of WTO
member countries agreed on a declaration consisting of 23 statements
that in essence summarized and affirmed all actions taken in
implementing of the Uruguay Round trade accords.
The dynamism in the international, regional and national
economy underscores the importance of strengthening the
fundamentals of our economy and thereby achieving great
resilience and competitiveness. Under these circumstances, we
need to increase competitive advantage not only at the corporate
level, but also in our national economy as a whole. At the
national level, it is essential to maintain economic and monetary
stability, build solid institutions, create a conducive business
environment, and continue improving the quality of human
resources.
The Indonesian economy posted high economic growth in 1995.
Nevertheless, the high growth was achieved at the price of
overheating, with the symptoms apparent in several economic
indicator. Non-oil/gas imports rose sharply, which outpaced non-
oil/gas export growth, and adding to this burden were rapidly
increasing imports of services.
As a result, the pressure on the balance of payments
heightened, resulting in the widening of current account deficit.
Inflation, albeit down from the previous year, remained above the
5 percent target established for Repelita VI as well as those in
many neighboring countries.
Without appropriate measures to bring the inflation down, our
economic development will be hard to sustain. True, high economic
growth helps to solve some of the problems facing our society, such
as the need to create employment and raise public incomes. However,
we have to ensure that achieving high economic growth should not at
the expense of macroeconomic stability which is the main foundation
for a sustainable growth.
In light of the development above, in 1996 the government
put high priority to the efforts to cool down the economy while
avoiding drastic measures that could produce unintended shocks in
the economy. To this end, the government is firmly committed to
prudent macroeconomic management. On the fiscal side, the
government has maintained a balanced budged policy aimed at
achieving substantial government savings, to be used not only to
finance development projects, but also to prepay high-interest
foreign debt.
The monetary authority has also maintained a prudent monetary
policy with the objective of keeping domestic demand growth in line
with the production capacity of the economy. To support this
policy, open market operations have been strengthened while
changes have been introduced in the statutory reserve
requirement.
Banks have also been required to keep their credit expansion
within the limits set out in their Annual Work Plans, which are
based on the past performance of the bank and prudential banking
practices.
Furthermore, to anticipate even stronger capital inflows in
the future, the monetary authority has introduced greater
flexibility into the rupiah exchange rate vis-a-vis the United
States dollar by widening the intervention band from 3 percent to
5 percent in June 1996 and to 8 percent in September 1996.
In another measure to support exports, on Dec. 31, 1996,
Bank Indonesia lowered the interest rate on rediscounted export
drafts from 2.5 percent to only 1.0 percent above SIBOR. For
export drafts issued by exporters meet a certain criteria, the
rediscount rate was lowered from 1 percent above SIBOR to SIBOR
only.
Bank Indonesia has also amended regulations on domestic letters
of credit (SKBDN) including an introduction of new regulation
regarding the trading of claims arising from SKBDN to Bank
Indonesia. This facility may be utilized by banks that purchased the
claims from companies that supply goods to certain exporters. The
short term objective of all these measures are to facilitate flows
of goods and services, while in the longer term improving economic
efficiency and expanding production capacity of the economy.
These economic policies have brought about some positive
developments as reflected in various macroeconomic indicators. Non-
oil/gas import growth, for example, has moderated.
Preliminary figures show that non-oil/gas import growth is
estimated at only 10 percent for 1996, considerably down from 26
percent in the previous year. Growth in various monetary
aggregates has also showed down. Annualized growth in M2, which
climbed to as high as 31 percent in May 1996, decelerated to 26
percent by the end of the year. Similarly, growth in bank
financing for the business sector, that encompasses not only
loans based on loan agreements, but also securities, equity
participation and other forms of financing, came down from 22
percent to about 19.8 percent.
Upward pressures on prices have also lightened. Cumulative
inflation, which reached 8.6 percent in 1995, fell to 6.5
percent. Although the growth rate is not as high as before, the
Indonesian economy is still projected to achieve a robust growth
of about 7.8 percent for 1996.
These developments are indeed heartening. Nevertheless, we
should not relax our vigilance against the possibility of
a resurgence of overheating. Close examination of macroeconomic
indicators shows that we must remain vigilant against the
possibility of resurgence in domestic demand.
First, while non-oil/gas imports grew at a modest pace in 1996,
the growth was unevenly distributed. Imports of consumer goods were
still relatively high. Similarly, strong growth can be expected
in imports of capital goods as a result of the implementation of
foreign and domestic investment approvals, which have recorded
remarkable growth over the past years.
Second, the growth of some monetary aggregates, such as bank
credit and M2, continued to exceed the desired targets despite
having eased to some extent. In addition, lending related to the
financing of domestic demand, such as property and consumer credit,
remains high.
Third, lower inflation in 1996 was mostly due to a decline in
food prices following its sharp increase at the beginning of the
year. In contrast, the increase in prices of non-food and energy
items, around 8 percent, remained relatively high. Inflation
rate, therefore, will continue to be sensitive to any sharp
increase in good prices.
These trends indicate that the overheating of the economy has
not fully subsided. In addition, it is important to maintain
vigilance on the susceptibility of foreign exchange market to
various domestic and international turbulence.
Experience over the past few years has shown that
disruptions in the financial markets can also result from non-
economic factors. This means that we still have to encounter
difficult challenges this year, particularly when we take into
account last year's lackluster performance of non-oil/gas
exports.
Like in the recent years, non-oil/gas export is expected to
fall from 14.2 percent in 1995/96 to 11.7 percent in 1996/97. The
slowing down of exports growth of some major commodities, such as
timber, reflects the difficulties regarding raw materials as well
as other problems facing the industry.
In addition, the entry of new competitors in the international
market has led to more competitive environment for some of
Indonesia's key export products, including textiles, garments, and
footwear. Exports of non-oil/gas primary products, particularly
agricultural commodities, have also suffered from weakening world
prices.
But we started to witness a more diversified export of
commodities. The share of the top 20 commodities as a percentage
of total exports has declined, while new commodities that have
only been exported since 1993 start to penetrate world markets.
Most of these new commodities are manufactured products, to name
a view are jewelry, computers and computer parts.
As a result of weakened export growth, the current account
deficit is projected to reach US$8.8 billion for the 1996/97,
equivalent to about 4.0 percent of the GDP. However, with strong
fundamentals in the economy and a conducive investment climate,
the capital account shows strong capitals inflows. This influx of
capital, especially from the private sector, has resulted a
surplus in the overall balance of payments. At the end of 1996,
official reserves stood at US$19.1 billion, sufficient for 4.8
months of non-oil/gas imports.
In 1996, capital transactions were marked by a continued
decline of net government borrowings, while the share of net inflows
of the private sector continued to increase. Out of a total of about
US$110 billion in outstanding debt in 1996, 51 percent or US$56
billion comprised government borrowings.
Compared to 1995, government debt declined US$2.9 billion as a
result of the weakening yen against the United States dollar, and
the prepayment of loans. Although government debts had declined, the
overall debt service ratio (DSR) for 1996/97 is projected to
remain relatively high namely 31.7 percent though a little lower
than for the previous year of 32.8 percent. Reasons for this high
DSR include slowing down of export growth, an increase in private
sector borrowing, and prepayment of Government debt. I should
add, however, that the prepayment of Government loans will help
bring down the Government DSR in the future.
Along with its increasing role in national development, the
private sector borrowing in the international market has surged. By
the end of 1996, the commercial offshore borrowing by private sector
had reached US$54 billion. The surge in private sector borrowings
prompted, Bank Indonesia to issue the Yankee Bonds in July 1996
with the objective to establish a benchmark for future issuance.
The success of the Yankee Bonds has helped the business community
in obtaining loans in the United States capital market at more
favorable terms, thereby easing the repayment burden borne by
private companies and in turn would ease pressure on the balance
of payments.
Along with the surging of commercial offshore borrowing by the
private sector, there has been rapid growth in foreign portfolio
investment. This has been driven by the attractive investment
climate as well as the robust performance of the capital market
and high domestic interest rates relative to other countries.
There are two points that I would like to bring out concerning
capital inflows.
First, we are all aware that foreign funds have a very positive
impact to our economy as one of the alternative sources of financing
economic development. However, these positive benefits can only be
realized if the prerequisites for attracting foreign capital
inflows are in place -- prudent macroeconomic management and the
sound development of financial markets.
Without these necessary conditions, foreign capital inflows can
lead to undesired development in our economy. Mexico's financial
crisis at the end of 1994 illustrates an example of the
consequences of failure in managing capital inflows, and in
particular the short term funds which are sensitive to economic
and non-economic disruptions.
Second, the brisk growth in private sector borrowing requires
sound allocation of these funds. We must ensure that these funds
are used more appropriately and efficiently and allocated to more
productive activities. These funds should mainly be used to
finance export oriented activities that will support their
repayment. Misallocation use of foreign borrowings will create
problems for the future given already large foreign debt and high
debt service ratio.
The encouraging economic performance has created a positive
climate for the ongoing process of consolidation in the banking
system. During 1996, Bank Indonesia adopted a series of measures
aimed at strengthening the foundation for the banking industry.
These policies seek to reinforce self regulatory banking
practices in order to enable banks implementing more sound risk
management.
Key to this is to encourage banks to adopt Bank Indonesia
guidance into their internal procedures. In view of this, serious
efforts from the banking sector are needed to achieve a sound and
secure national banking system.
Bank Indonesia also introduced several policies and measures
related to the settlement of problem loans. Efforts are under way to
encourage banks with sufficient reserves to write off their bad
debts. In carrying out this program, Bank Indonesia needs closer
coordination with other competent institutions. Bank Indonesia has
undertaken a comprehensive study on ways and strategies of dealing
with problem banks.
These efforts are linked to the completion of a regulation
on bank liquidation, now issued as government regulation No. 68
of 1996 concerning Regulations and Procedure for Revocation of
Bank Operating Licenses and the closure and liquidation of Banks.
As part of the banking restructuring program, Bank Indonesia
has adopted further measures designed to encourage mergers and
consolidations. These measures may be voluntary, such as those
aimed at increasing the competitiveness of Indonesian banks or
they may be compulsory related to the efforts in solving problem
banks. These restructuring policies are aimed at creating a solid
Indonesian banking structure consisting of both large and small
banks with branches commensurate with the availability of
personnel, economic conditions, and technology.
Related to the measures aimed at promoting the consolidation of
the banking system, Bank Indonesia is constantly improving the
supervision of banking industry, particularly in areas concerning
the implementation of prudent banking principles. In this regard,
to ascertain the level of compliance with Legal Lending Limit
regulation while finding out the difficulties confronting banks,
Bank Indonesia has conducted special examination of all
commercial banks. Against bank violating the Legal Lending Limit
regulation, Bank Indonesia has started intensifying Cease and
Desist Orders (CDOs), among others, by implementing Criteria of
Reprehensible Acts Precluding Persons from Holding Positions as
Banks Shareholders or Bank Management to bank management and
related personnel responsible for failure in solving the
violations.
With respect to the development of capital market, Bank
Indonesia is constantly reviewing the involvement of bank in the
capital market. I would like to stress that careful consideration is
needed in this matter to ensure that it is not at the expense of
ongoing consolidation process and the prudential principles.
To deal with bank fraud, Bank Indonesia is coordinating its
efforts with other related institutions. Currently, a possibility to
grant Bank Indonesia an authority to conduct investigations of bank
fraud is now under way. In this regard, Bank Indonesia may work
with the police and/or the Attorney General in a mutually
supportive capacity. Bank Indonesia may conduct investigations on
the more technical side of the fraudulent activities, while the
criminal aspects are handled by the police or the Attorney
General. Related to this cooperation, the coordinated forum for
bad debt settlements has been broadened since early 1996 to
include the Chief of National Police Force.
In an effort to step up the effectiveness of bank supervision,
Bank Indonesia launched a pilot scheme in 1996 intended to seek for
the possibility of bank examination by chartered public accountants.
An initiative is also under way to improve the terms of reference of
bank examination through an advanced pilot examination now taking
place with eight banks suffered from more complicated problems.
Overall, the number of commercial banks has stayed fairly
constant with 239 in Indonesia at the end of the year, down by
one from 1995. However, the number of bank offices increased by
493 during the year, with most of these opened by private foreign
exchange banks. The number of rural banks also went up by 48,
bringing the total established under the new banking act to
1,996.
In banking operations, Indonesia also experienced
substantial growth in overall banking assets. As I mentioned
earlier, bank credit in its broad meaning increased by 19.8
percent during 1996. This growth was substantially higher than
the 17 percent expansion targeted in the annual work plans. Much
of this credit expansion was absorbed by industry, followed by
services and commerce. However, in terms of growth rates, credit
to the services sector recorded by far the highest expansion
especially to the property sector. In terms of the use of credit,
highest expansion was recorded for consumption purposes, followed
by credit for working capital and investment.
That high growth in the asset side was supported by an increase
of savings mobilization. During the year, demand deposits, savings,
and time deposits recorded about 29 percent growth. At the same
time, bank capital, consisting of paid up capital, reserves and
earnings, increased by 18 percent with most of this growth
resulting from additional paid up capital. It seems that during
1996 banks did not experience any serious difficulties in
accumulating funds needed to finance their operations.
Nevertheless, as I have emphasized at last year's dinner,
these activities, particularly those linked to derivative
transactions, demand considerable cautions from the banking
communities regarding the high risks involved. Since the ratio of
off balance sheet liabilities against capital has increased from
6.6 times to 8 times, I would like to remind banks to apply
appropriate and sound risk management on the basis of prudential
banking principles.
As a new capital adequacy ratio will be effective in September
1997, 223 banks or 93 percent of total banks have already met the
requirements. The average CAR is above 12 percent, and each
category of banks has already surpassed 10 percent. As a group,
joint venture banks have gone as far as achieving a CAR or 15
percent. Overall, banks that failed to achieve compliance with
the CAR has declined from 21 banks at the end of 1995 to 16
banks.
Nevertheless, the record of compliance with the regulations
governing the legal lending limit, small-scale business credit,
and export credit during the past year remains discouraging.
During 1996, more banks violated the legal lending limit and the
small-scale business credit requirement.
There has also been a similar trend observed in violations
by foreign and joint venture banks of the export credit
requirement. I would like to urge banks that are still falling
short of the requirements of these banking regulations to show
more serious efforts to meet the requirements.
Window A: Experience over the past few years has shown that
disruptions in the financial markets can also result from non-
economic factors.
Window B: Nevertheless, the record of compliance with the
regulations governing the legal lending limit, small-scale
business credit, and export credit during the past year
remains discouraging.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/banking-developments-in-1996-and-policy-directions-for-1997-1447893297-1532784)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post