Bandung Council Suspects Planned Tree Felling, Urges Corporate Prosecution
The Bandung City Council (DPRD) has alleged that the felling of 10 trees on a city roadside was a planned and organised action, not a spontaneous act. Commissioner I of the DPRD, Radea Respati Paramudhita, stated that the incident is strongly suspected to be connected to the construction of a padel sports facility at the location.
“Cutting down that many trees is impossible for an individual without a structure, equipment, or support vehicles. I strongly suspect this was an organised action, backed by a financier, and linked to the padel court development,” Radea said.
He emphasised that such violations could be prevented with strong synergy between the public and the council. Radea noted that the council’s oversight function can only be optimal if supported by active community participation and local authorities in reporting irregularities, a challenge given the council’s 50 members must cover 30 districts.
Radea appreciated the swift public reprimand issued by the Bandung Mayor, viewing it as an effective warning to other potential violators. However, he stressed that this must be followed by more substantial legal proceedings. He highlighted the irony that a sports facility, intended to promote public health, was allegedly built by disregarding environmental preservation.
As a business law expert, Radea insisted that legal action must target the beneficial owners of the business entity suspected to be behind the incident, not just field workers. He suspects the padel business owner likely operates under a Limited Liability Company (PT) or a Limited Partnership (CV), and the mayor’s reprimand should be directed at that entity.
He urged the Bandung City Government to apply the principle of corporate criminal liability. Under this mechanism, the tree felling can be categorised as both an environmental crime and a violation of local regulations, allowing criminal responsibility to extend to owners, managers, and commissioners if their involvement is proven.
Beyond criminal proceedings, Radea pushed for a civil lawsuit to demand compensation for environmental restoration. He argued that the ecological damage would be disproportionate if the compensation were merely symbolic. “Don’t let a large tree be replaced with a small one,” he said. He explained that civil and criminal pathways serve different but complementary purposes in business crime, with civil law focusing on restorative balance and criminal law on deterrence.
Radea also criticised the internal oversight of the suspected company, pointing out that a Board of Commissioners exists to monitor directors’ actions but often chooses to condone them instead. He argued that scrutiny for supervisory negligence should also fall on the company’s Board of Commissioners, as the tree felling was closely tied to a business decision by the directors.
He called on the city government to take immediate, concrete legal steps rather than just issuing threats, recommending a civil lawsuit with a value commensurate with the ecological loss. “My advice is to report it directly. File a proportionate lawsuit,” he said. He compared the case to corporate pollution incidents, where legal action typically targets the business entity. Radea specifically recommended three steps: identifying and prosecuting the beneficial owner, applying corporate criminal liability, and filing a civil lawsuit for compensation and environmental recovery.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/bandung-council-suspects-planned-tree-felling-urges-corporate-prosecution-1786272744)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260809162544-25-1390340/duga-penebangan-10-pohon-terencana-dprd-bandung-desak-langkah-hukum), translated from Indonesian