Bahlil Named Among Worst-Performing Ministers in Celios List; Golkar Says It Must Not Be Used for Personal Attacks
Jakarta – Ahmad Labib, a member of Commission VI of the House of Representatives (DPR), has responded to a survey released by the Center of Economic and Law Studies (Celios), which placed Energy and Mineral Resources Minister and Golkar Party chairman Bahlil Lahadalia among the worst-performing ministers.
The Golkar politician stressed that research and surveys should serve as scientific, objective and measurable instruments for evaluating policy, rather than being downgraded into vehicles for public opinion that attack an individual or their character.
He said it was regrettable if research institutions appeared to be chasing sensational headlines to boost their own popularity and public profile, while disregarding academic standards, research methodology and evidence of actual achievements in the field.
Ahmad Labib said any research or survey claiming to be scientific must have transparent, robust criteria and methodology that can be publicly scrutinised.
“An assessment of a minister’s performance must not rely solely on qualitative perceptions, which are vulnerable to bias arising from vested interests or social-media sentiment. It must instead be tested using valid statistical analytical tools and objective key performance indicators (KPIs),” he said in a written statement on Wednesday (14 October 2026).
He said credible survey parameters should meet at least four basic requirements: a measurable population and representative sample; clear quantitative performance indicators; verifiable data-analysis tools; and an independent research institution free from political agendas and the pursuit of instant publicity.
Ahmad Labib argued that objective data and Bahlil Lahadalia’s actual achievements pointed to a reality contrary to the survey’s narrative.
“According to official Energy and Mineral Resources Ministry data, under Bahlil’s leadership, non-tax state revenue (PNBP) in 2025 reached Rp138.40 trillion, or 108.56 per cent of the Rp127.48 trillion target. The ministry also regained an unqualified opinion from the Audit Board of Indonesia (BPK) on its 2025 financial statements,” he said.
The positive trend continued: by July 2026, the ministry had collected Rp96.26 trillion in PNBP, equal to 70.69 per cent of this year’s target of Rp136.18 trillion.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/bahlil-named-among-worst-performing-ministers-in-celios-list-golkar-says-it-must-not-be-used-for-personal-1791960666)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1935686-bahlil-masuk-daftar-menteri-dengan-kinerja-terburuk-versi-celios-golkar-jangan-jadikan-alat-serang-personal), translated from Indonesian